With all these problems, misunderstandings, and my lack of explaining things, I should've allowed time to discuss this first.

But we should be getting this back on track. I even changed the title for it to possibly make more sense / sound more clear and will be sure to highlight the fact this list will be based on entire careers on the next one.

The next list will be RB's and I'll post that in a day or two. If you haven't rated the QB's, do that shit.

Well fuck yes.

Man, these niggas trippin

Quit being a pussy and make your ratings.

Thought about this again..... forget literally everything I just said. Even though I prefer it, I feel like this list will get complicated and have a lot of differing reasons for people getting high/low ratings that way.


Everyone make their ratings based on how good you think they are currently. That doesn't mean base it off of only last season, but what they have done recently should play a huge factor into the rating that you give them. If you want to look back at their careers to try to justify (to yourself) that they are still as good as they used to be or anything like that when making your rating, that is fine and up to your personal preference. But we will be rating them mainly on their recent production/accomplishments/skillset.

I'm changing the title back to what it was & making a new thread to start this over.