Rate each player out of 10 (0 rating allowed; 1/2 ratings allowed) based on their entire careers, but considering this is a current list, your judgment of their current production & skillset should have just a little more emphasis on your ratings.

You can judge what each rating between the 0-10 scale means to you (ex: 0 = out of the league in a few years, 10 = future HOF, etc. is really up to you) but try to stay consistent with those ratings for each player/position.


Aaron Rodgers
Alex Smith
Andrew Luck
Andy Dalton
Ben Roethlisberger
Cam Newton
Carson Palmer
Chad Henne
Christian Ponder
Colin Kaepernick
Drew Brees
EJ Manuel
Eli Manning
Geno Smith
Jake Locker
Jason Campbell
Jay Cutler
Joe Flacco
Josh Freeman
Josh McCown
Kyle Orton
Mark Sanchez
Matt Cassel
Matt Ryan
Matt Schaub
Matthew Stafford
Michael Vick
Mike Glennon
Nick Foles
Peyton Manning
Philip Rivers
Robert Griffin III
Russell Wilson
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Ryan Tannehill
Sam Bradford
Tom Brady
Tony Romo


Picked 38 current QB's who have basically had to play roughly one season and/or at least have had flashes of playing well. Wanted to cut it down a little more but any more would really be based on personal preference so this is fine. Quite a bit shouldn't be making the top 200 list regardless. But it's time to see how this goes

Aaron Rodgers - 9.5
Alex Smith - 5.5
Andrew Luck - 8.5
Andy Dalton - 5
Ben Roethlisberger - 7.5
Cam Newton - 7
Carson Palmer - 5
Chad Henne - 4
Christian Ponder - 3
Colin Kaepernick - 7
Drew Brees - 9
EJ Manuel - 6
Eli Manning - 6
Geno Smith - 7
Jake Locker - 6
Jason Campbell - 3
Jay Cutler - 7
Joe Flacco - 6
Josh Freeman - 6
Josh McCown - 5.5
Kyle Orton - 5
Mark Sanchez - 5
Matt Cassel - 4
Matt Ryan - 8
Matt Schaub - 5
Matthew Stafford - 8
Michael Vick - 4.5
Mike Glennon - 6
Nick Foles - 7.5
Peyton Manning - 10
Philip Rivers - 8
Robert Griffin III - 6.5
Russell Wilson - 7.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 5
Ryan Tannehill - 6.5
Sam Bradford - 6
Tom Brady - 9
Tony Romo - 7

Jebus that's a lot.

Aaron Rodgers - 9
Alex Smith - 7
Andrew Luck - 6.5
Andy Dalton - 4
Ben Roethlisberger - 8.5
Cam Newton - 8
Carson Palmer - 7.5
Chad Henne - 3.5
Christian Ponder - 4.5
Colin Kaepernick - 6.5
Drew Brees - 9.5
EJ Manuel - 5
Eli Manning - 8
Geno Smith - 5
Jake Locker - 6
Jason Campbell - 5
Jay Cutler - 6
Joe Flacco - 6
Josh Freeman - 4.5
Josh McCown - 4.5
Kyle Orton - 3.5
Mark Sanchez - 5.5
Matt Cassel - 6
Matt Ryan - 7
Matt Schaub - 7
Matthew Stafford - 8
Michael Vick - 8
Mike Glennon - 5
Nick Foles - 4.5
Peyton Manning - 9.5
Philip Rivers - 8.5
Robert Griffin III - 8
Russell Wilson - 7.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 5.5
Ryan Tannehill - 6
Sam Bradford - 6
Tom Brady - 9
Tony Romo - 7.5

Aaron Rodgers - 9.5
Alex Smith - 6.5
Andrew Luck - 8
Andy Dalton - 7
Ben Roethlisberger - 8
Cam Newton - 8.5
Carson Palmer - 6.5
Chad Henne - 2.5
Christian Ponder - 2
Colin Kaepernick - 7
Drew Brees - 10
EJ Manuel - 4.5
Eli Manning - 6.5
Geno Smith - 5
Jake Locker - 6
Jason Campbell - 5.5
Jay Cutler - 6.5
Joe Flacco - 7
Josh Freeman - 5.5
Josh McCown - 5
Kyle Orton - 5
Mark Sanchez - 5.5
Matt Cassel - 4
Matt Ryan - 7
Matt Schaub - 6
Matthew Stafford - 8
Michael Vick - 7.5
Mike Glennon - 5.5
Nick Foles - 6.5
Peyton Manning - 10
Philip Rivers - 8.5
Robert Griffin III - 7.5
Russell Wilson - 7.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 5.5
Ryan Tannehill - 6.5
Sam Bradford - 5.5
Tom Brady - 10
Tony Romo - 8

^^ Yeah, it is. Most of the other positions will include even more. Wanted to cut this down to like 25-30 but meh, the extra QB's on there won't do any harm anyway.

lol this is the dumbest shit i have ever seen   

will edit post later

Aaron Rodgers - 9.5
Alex Smith - 7
Andrew Luck - 8
Andy Dalton - 5
Ben Roethlisberger - 8
Cam Newton - 8.5
Carson Palmer - 6
Chad Henne - 2
Christian Ponder - 2
Colin Kaepernick - 8
Drew Brees - 10
EJ Manuel - 3.5
Eli Manning - 6
Geno Smith - 4
Jake Locker - 6
Jason Campbell - 1.5
Jay Cutler - 7
Joe Flacco - 5.5
Josh Freeman - 3
Josh McCown - 5
Kyle Orton - 1.5
Mark Sanchez - 2
Matt Cassel - 2.5
Matt Ryan - 8
Matt Schaub - 3
Matthew Stafford - 8.5
Michael Vick - 5
Mike Glennon - 4.5
Nick Foles - 8
Peyton Manning - 10
Philip Rivers - 8
Robert Griffin III - 7
Russell Wilson - 7.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 1
Ryan Tannehill - 6
Sam Bradford - 4
Tom Brady - 9
Tony Romo - 7

@ Huh


Also ^ another Tony Romo under-rater

Since you love Romo so much I thought I'd let you know I ranked them before I gave ratings and I have Cutler above Romo

(oh and another Matt Ryan over-rater too )

Nah, yo bitchass just underrates him.

Aaron Rodgers - 8
Alex Smith - 5.5
Andrew Luck - 7
Andy Dalton - 6
Ben Roethlisberger - 5
Cam Newton - 7.5
Carson Palmer - 5
Chad Henne - 3
Christian Ponder - 5
Colin Kaepernick - 3
Drew Brees - 10
EJ Manuel - 6
Eli Manning - 4
Geno Smith - 5
Jake Locker - 5.5
Jason Campbell - 5
Jay Cutler - 6
Joe Flacco - 6.5
Josh Freeman - 4
Josh McCown - 4.5
Kyle Orton - 5
Mark Sanchez - 6.5
Matt Cassel - 6
Matt Ryan - 6.5
Matt Schaub - 6
Matthew Stafford - 7
Michael Vick - 0
Mike Glennon - 4
Nick Foles - 7.5
Peyton Manning - 9.5
Philip Rivers - 7
Robert Griffin III - 3.5
Russell Wilson - 6.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 5.5
Ryan Tannehill - 6
Sam Bradford - 6
Tom Brady - 10
Tony Romo - 9

Razor's ratings made me LOL

Mack, learn how to quote, you ho ass nigga.

Señor Mexicano wrote:

Razor's ratings made me LOL

They're not really that off. Except for maybe Matt Ryans and RG3

Am I allowed to bump my rating for Vick up to compensate for Razor's dumbassity?

Aaron Rodgers 9.5
Alex Smith 7
Andrew Luck 7.5
Andy Dalton 6.5
Ben Roethlisberger 7.5
Cam Newton 7.5
Carson Palmer 7
Chad Henne 6
Christian Ponder 5.5
Colin Kaepernick 7.5
Drew Brees 9
EJ Manuel 6
Eli Manning 7
Geno Smith 6.5
Jake Locker 7
Jason Campbell 6
Jay Cutler 8
Joe Flacco 7
Josh Freeman 4.5
Josh McCown 6.5
Kyle Orton 6.5
Mark Sanchez 6.5
Matt Cassel 6.5
Matt Ryan 7.5
Matt Schaub 7
Matthew Stafford 7.5
Michael Vick 6.5
Mike Glennon 7
Nick Foles 7.5
Peyton Manning 9
Philip Rivers 8
Robert Griffin III 7.5
Russell Wilson 7.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick 6.5
Ryan Tannehill 7
Sam Bradford 7.5
Tom Brady 9
Tony Romo 8

Michael Vick shouldn't even be on the list, he should be fired and have his head cut off. Disgusting piece of shit.

On Field =/= Off field.

Sure he's a dick, but it doesn't mean he isn't good. It's like saying Chris Benoit was a bad wrestler. It's just dumb.

He's not good either. It's my own ranking anyway, quit being such a baby about it. I think he deserves to be at a 0, so that is what I gave him. Get over it.

Well you throw off the entire system...