Everyone make your ratings based on their recent production/accomplishments/skillset. That doesn't mean base it off of only last season, but what they have done recently should be a huge factor into the rating that you give them. If you want to look back at their careers to try to justify (to yourself) that they are still as good as they used to be or anything like that when making your rating, that is fine and up to your personal preference. But we will be rating them mainly on the present and very recent past.

Rate each player from 1-10 (1/2 ratings allowed). You can judge what each rating between the 1-10 scale means to you (ex: 1 = out of the league in a few years, 10 = future HOF, etc. is really up to you) but try to stay consistent with those ratings for each player/position.

Any ratings that are 2.5+ points under or over the average rating will be considered outliers and won't be counted.


Adrian Peterson
Ahmad Bradshaw
Alfred Morris
Andre Brown
Andre Ellington
Arian Foster
Ben Tate
BenJarvus Green-Ellis
Bernard Pierce
Bilal Powell
Chris Ivory
Chris Johnson
C.J. Spiller
Danny Woodhead
Darren McFadden
Darren Sproles
DeAngelo Williams
DeMarco Murray
Donald Brown
Doug Martin
Eddie Lacy
Frank Gore
Fred Jackson
Giovani Bernard
Jamaal Charles
James Starks
Joique Bell
Jonathan Stewart
Knowshon Moreno
Lamar Miller
LeGarrette Blount
LeSean McCoy
LeVeon Bell
Mark Ingram
Marshawn Lynch
Matt Forte
Maurice Jones-Drew
Montee Ball
Peyton Hillis
Pierre Thomas
Rashad Jennings
Ray Rice
Reggie Bush
Roy Helu
Ryan Mathews
Shane Vereen
Shonn Greene
Stevan Ridley
Steven Jackson
Toby Gerhart
Trent Richardson
Zac Stacy

Adrian Peterson - 10
Ahmad Bradshaw - 6
Alfred Morris - 8
Andre Brown - 5
Andre Ellington - 6.5
Arian Foster - 8.5
Ben Tate - 6.5
BenJarvus Green-Ellis - 5
Bernard Pierce - 5.5
Bilal Powell - 5.5
Chris Ivory - 7
Chris Johnson - 7.5
C.J. Spiller - 7.5
Danny Woodhead - 6
Darren McFadden - 7
Darren Sproles - 6.5
DeAngelo Williams - 6
DeMarco Murray - 8
Donald Brown - 6
Doug Martin - 7.5
Eddie Lacy - 8
Frank Gore - 8
Fred Jackson - 7
Giovani Bernard - 7.5
Jamaal Charles - 9.5
James Starks - 3
Joique Bell - 7
Jonathan Stewart - 5
Knowshon Moreno - 7
Lamar Miller - 5.5
LeGarrette Blount - 5
LeSean McCoy - 10
LeVeon Bell - 7.5
Mark Ingram - 5
Marshawn Lynch - 9
Matt Forte - 8.5
Maurice Jones-Drew - 7.5
Montee Ball - 5.5
Peyton Hillis - 5
Pierre Thomas - 6.5
Rashad Jennings - 7
Ray Rice - 7.5
Reggie Bush - 7.5
Roy Helu - 6
Ryan Mathews - 7.5
Shane Vereen - 6
Shonn Greene - 6.5
Stevan Ridley - 7
Steven Jackson - 7
Toby Gerhart - 6.5
Trent Richardson - 7
Zac Stacy - 7.5

No one else rated yet... I'll be the first to go then.

Not sure how you selected which RB's to use but Vick Ballard has definitely played enough to warrant a ranking. (He won't make the top 200 I'm sure so including him isn't a big deal)

Adrian Peterson - 10
Ahmad Bradshaw - 3
Alfred Morris - 8.5
Andre Brown - 2.5
Andre Ellington - 4
Arian Foster - 8.5
Ben Tate - 6.5
BenJarvus Green-Ellis - 5.5
Bernard Pierce - 4.5
Bilal Powell - 3
Chris Ivory - 4
Chris Johnson - 6
C.J. Spiller - 8
Danny Woodhead - 6
Darren McFadden - 5
Darren Sproles - 7
DeAngelo Williams - 7
DeMarco Murray - 7.5
Donald Brown - 2.5
Doug Martin - 8.5
Eddie Lacy - 8
Frank Gore - 8
Fred Jackson - 7
Giovani Bernard - 7
Jamaal Charles - 9.5
James Starks - 2
Joique Bell - 5.5
Jonathan Stewart - 3.5
Knowshon Moreno - 7
Lamar Miller - 4.5
LeGarrette Blount - 6
LeSean McCoy - 9.5
LeVeon Bell - 7
Mark Ingram - 3
Marshawn Lynch - 9
Matt Forte - 9
Maurice Jones-Drew - 5
Montee Ball - 5.5
Peyton Hillis - 4
Pierre Thomas - 4.5
Rashad Jennings - 3.5
Ray Rice - 6.5
Reggie Bush - 7.5
Roy Helu - 3
Ryan Mathews - 7.5
Shane Vereen - 3.5
Shonn Greene - 3
Stevan Ridley - 5
Steven Jackson - 6
Toby Gerhart - 6.5
Trent Richardson - 2
Zac Stacy - 7.5

^ You hatin hard on some niggas ... Like Trent.. & Ivory.


Might change my ratings a little bit tomorrow. Just realized I stacked too many people very close in rating at a certain point when really they're not all on the same level.

Trent has legit been one of the worst RB's in the league since he got drafted. Ivory looked better as a secondary back on the Saints than he did as a starter in New York.

Damn, this nigga Red Sox be going harsh on the RBs.

Adrian Peterson 9.5
Ahmad Bradshaw 6.5
Alfred Morris 8.5
Andre Brown 5.5
Andre Ellington 8
Arian Foster 7.5
Ben Tate 7
BenJarvus Green-Ellis 6
Bernard Pierce 7
Bilal Powell 6
Chris Ivory 7
Chris Johnson 7
C.J. Spiller 7.5
Danny Woodhead 6.5
Darren McFadden 7
Darren Sproles 7
DeAngelo Williams 7.5
DeMarco Murray 8
Donald Brown 7
Doug Martin 8.5
Eddie Lacy 8.5
Frank Gore 7.5
Fred Jackson 7
Giovani Bernard 8
Jamaal Charles 9
James Starks 6
Joique Bell 7.5
Jonathan Stewart 7.5
Knowshon Moreno 7
Lamar Miller 7.5
LeGarrette Blount 7
LeSean McCoy 9.5
LeVeon Bell 8
Mark Ingram 7
Marshawn Lynch 8
Matt Forte 9
Maurice Jones-Drew 7.5
Montee Ball 8.5
Peyton Hillis 5.5
Pierre Thomas 7
Rashad Jennings 6.5
Ray Rice 8
Reggie Bush 7
Roy Helu 6.5
Ryan Mathews 8
Shane Vereen 7
Shonn Greene 6.5
Stevan Ridley 7
Steven Jackson 6.5
Toby Gerhart 7.5
Trent Richardson 7
Zac Stacy 8

Adrian Peterson - 10
Ahmad Bradshaw - 6
Alfred Morris - 8
Andre Brown - 5
Andre Ellington - 6.5
Arian Foster - 8.5
Ben Tate - 6.5
BenJarvus Green-Ellis - 5
Bernard Pierce - 5.5
Bilal Powell - 5.5
Chris Ivory - 7
Chris Johnson - 7.5
C.J. Spiller - 7.5
Danny Woodhead - 6
Darren McFadden - 7
Darren Sproles - 6.5
DeAngelo Williams - 6
DeMarco Murray - 8
Donald Brown - 6
Doug Martin - 7.5
Eddie Lacy - 8
Frank Gore - 8
Fred Jackson - 7
Giovani Bernard - 7.5
Jamaal Charles - 9.5
James Starks - 3
Joique Bell - 7
Jonathan Stewart - 5
Knowshon Moreno - 7
Lamar Miller - 5.5
LeGarrette Blount - 5
LeSean McCoy - 10
LeVeon Bell - 7.5
Mark Ingram - 5
Marshawn Lynch - 9
Matt Forte - 8.5
Maurice Jones-Drew - 7.5
Montee Ball - 5.5
Peyton Hillis - 5
Pierre Thomas - 6.5
Rashad Jennings - 7
Ray Rice - 7.5
Reggie Bush - 7.5
Roy Helu - 6
Ryan Mathews - 7.5
Shane Vereen - 6
Shonn Greene - 6.5
Stevan Ridley - 7
Steven Jackson - 7
Toby Gerhart - 6.5
Trent Richardson - 7
Zac Stacy - 7.5

Copy/pasted my ratings.

Only 4 lists?????? (and Razor's obviously don't count lol)


This is already losing interest and we're just at the second list.

Mexi didn't do a list out of protest cause you didn't include Christine Michael

Had to cut it off somewhere and yards/carries were the main qualifying point. Players who have done little to nothing before last season also weren't given any slack while others around the same area in yards & carries last season may have gotten the benefit of the doubt for previous seasons.


Tell Mexi to stop being a Razor. Not like Christine Michael was making it anywhere near the top 200

This nigga Burdur includes all of the Jets' RB's, tho

But nah, I did one but I hit backspace and it went to the previous page then got mad and left. Never got to it.

Adrian Peterson - 10
Ahmad Bradshaw - 6.5
Alfred Morris - 8
Andre Brown - 5.5
Andre Ellington - 7
Arian Foster - 8
Ben Tate - 6.5
BenJarvus Green-Ellis - 6
Bernard Pierce - 6
Bilal Powell - 5.5
Chris Ivory 6.5
Chris Johnson 7
C.J. Spiller 7
Danny Woodhead 6
Darren McFadden 7
Darren Sproles 7
DeAngelo Williams 7
DeMarco Murray 8
Donald Brown 6.5
Doug Martin 7.5
Eddie Lacy 8.5
Frank Gore 7.5
Fred Jackson 7
Giovani Bernard 8.5
Jamaal Charles 9.5
James Starks 5.5
Joique Bell 7
Jonathan Stewart 6.5
Knowshon Moreno 7
Lamar Miller 7.5
LeGarrette Blount 6.5
LeSean McCoy 10
LeVeon Bell 8
Mark Ingram 5.5
Marshawn Lynch 9.5
Matt Forte 9
Maurice Jones-Drew 7.5
Montee Ball 6.5
Peyton Hillis 5.5
Pierre Thomas 7
Rashad Jennings 6
Ray Rice 8
Reggie Bush 7
Roy Helu 6
Ryan Mathews 7.5
Shane Vereen 7
Shonn Greene 6
Stevan Ridley 6.5
Steven Jackson 7
Toby Gerhart 7
Trent Richardson 6.5
Zac Stacy 8.5

Señor Drächen wrote:

This nigga Burdur includes all of the Jets' RB's, tho

That's cause those are some real niggas.


Also, I'll prob post the next list tomorrow morning/afternoon, if not later tonight.

Real garbage ass niggas.

Adrian Peterson - 10
Ahmad Bradshaw - 7
Alfred Morris - 8
Andre Brown - 6
Andre Ellington - 7
Arian Foster - 8.5
Ben Tate - 6.5
BenJarvus Green-Ellis - 5
Bernard Pierce - 6
Bilal Powell - Why is this nigga on the list he straight trash
Chris Ivory - 6
Chris Johnson - 6.5
C.J. Spiller - 7
Danny Woodhead - 6
Darren McFadden - 5
Darren Sproles - 6
DeAngelo Williams - 6
DeMarco Murray - 8
Donald Brown - 5
Doug Martin - 7
Eddie Lacy - 8
Frank Gore - 8
Fred Jackson - 7.5
Giovani Bernard - 7
Jamaal Charles 9.5
James Starks - 4
Joique Bell - 7
Jonathan Stewart - 6
Knowshon Moreno - 6
Lamar Miller - 5
LeGarrette Blount - 6
LeSean McCoy - 10
LeVeon Bell - 7.5
Mark Ingram - 7
Marshawn Lynch - 9.5
Matt Forte - 9
Maurice Jones-Drew - 7
Montee Ball - 6.5
Peyton Hillis - 5
Pierre Thomas - 6.5
Rashad Jennings - 6.5
Ray Rice - 8
Reggie Bush - 7.5
Roy Helu - 6
Ryan Mathews - 7.5
Shane Vereen - 6
Shonn Greene - 5
Stevan Ridley - 6.5
Steven Jackson - 6
Toby Gerhart - 6.5
Trent Richardson - 7
Zac Stacy - 7.5

Late