I wasn't saying anything to you.

Well if you don't want to continue and be the bigger person then just walk away and stop being a fucking moron and deleting posts that make you look bad.

You keep trying to start shit up what do you expect.

Damn I missed some shit.

but RGIII's rookie season was worthy of a 9 at least. One of the best rookie seasons of all time. Saying he hasn't done dick is patently false. He was not good last year, but he did already carry an awful team into the postseason.

Aaron Rodgers 9.5
Alex Smith 7
Andrew Luck 7.5
Andy Dalton 6.5
Ben Roethlisberger 7.5
Cam Newton 7.5
Carson Palmer 7
Chad Henne 6
Christian Ponder 5.5
Colin Kaepernick 7.5
Drew Brees 9
EJ Manuel 6
Eli Manning 7
Geno Smith 6.5
Jake Locker 7
Jason Campbell 6
Jay Cutler 8
Joe Flacco 7
Josh Freeman 4.5
Josh McCown 6.5
Kyle Orton 6.5
Mark Sanchez 6.5
Matt Cassel 6.5
Matt Ryan 7.5
Matt Schaub 7
Matthew Stafford 7.5
Michael Vick 6.5
Mike Glennon 7
Nick Foles 7.5
Peyton Manning 9
Philip Rivers 8
Robert Griffin III 7.5
Russell Wilson 7.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick 6.5
Ryan Tannehill 7
Sam Bradford 7.5
Tom Brady 9
Tony Romo 8

Quote :

Edit: Note, remember that only Ian, Mack, Mexi, Drachen, and maybe TJ can make their choices. No one else is a part of XWA and if anyone else decides to post, they will be treated with hostility and we will all be bitches if you don't agree with us.

Razor deserves a demotion for editing this into the first post.

Btw, 3 lists so far. Everyone else get your lists re-posted (or make your lists for the first time... *cough* Drachen *cough*).

Aaron Rodgers - 9.5
Alex Smith - 7
Andrew Luck - 8
Andy Dalton - 6
Ben Roethlisberger - 7
Cam Newton - 8.5
Carson Palmer - 5.5
Chad Henne - 3
Christian Ponder - 4
Colin Kaepernick - 7
Drew Brees - 10
EJ Manuel - 4.5
Eli Manning - 6
Geno Smith - 5.5
Jake Locker - 5.5
Jason Campbell - 4.5
Jay Cutler - 7
Joe Flacco - 7
Josh Freeman - 5
Josh McCown - 6
Kyle Orton - 3.5
Mark Sanchez - 5.5
Matt Cassel - 4
Matt Ryan - 7
Matt Schaub - 5.5
Matthew Stafford - 8.5
Michael Vick - 6.5
Mike Glennon - 4.5
Nick Foles - 6.5
Peyton Manning - 10
Philip Rivers - 8.5
Robert Griffin III - 7.5
Russell Wilson - 7.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 4
Ryan Tannehill - 6
Sam Bradford - 5
Tom Brady - 9.5
Tony Romo - 8

Aaron Rodgers - 9.5
Alex Smith - 7
Andrew Luck - 8
Andy Dalton - 5
Ben Roethlisberger - 8
Cam Newton - 8.5
Carson Palmer - 6
Chad Henne - 2
Christian Ponder - 2
Colin Kaepernick - 8
Drew Brees - 10
EJ Manuel - 3.5
Eli Manning - 6
Geno Smith - 4
Jake Locker - 6
Jason Campbell - 1.5
Jay Cutler - 7
Joe Flacco - 5.5
Josh Freeman - 3
Josh McCown - 5
Kyle Orton - 1.5
Mark Sanchez - 2
Matt Cassel - 2.5
Matt Ryan - 8
Matt Schaub - 3
Matthew Stafford - 8.5
Michael Vick - 5
Mike Glennon - 4.5
Nick Foles - 8
Peyton Manning - 10
Philip Rivers - 8
Robert Griffin III - 7
Russell Wilson - 7.5
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 1
Ryan Tannehill - 6
Sam Bradford - 4
Tom Brady - 9
Tony Romo - 7

Burdur wrote:

Quote :

Edit: Note, remember that only Ian, Mack, Mexi, Drachen, and maybe TJ can make their choices. No one else is a part of XWA and if anyone else decides to post, they will be treated with hostility and we will all be bitches if you don't agree with us.

Razor deserves a demotion for editing this into the first post.

But he's right, so you should just leave this part in.

If you don't know football  

Oh, so THAT'S why you're not posting your ratings.

Nah, you will be treated with hostility if you make dumbass picks. Quit bitching.

No, you get treated with hostility if you make picks people don't agree with. The difference is, I'm not a little bitch that edits my picks when I get dickslapped by Mack in an argument like you.

What a clever response. At least admit when I made a stupid ass pick. I'm not like your dumbass that admits ignorance on a subject then when you're called out on it, you double down on your hilarious ass ratings. Please, just get the fuck out of here, you have no business in this thread.

It's not a matter of disagreement with you, it's a matter of your picks being so off basis, that it makes experts want to commit suicide.

Should I respond to this comment, or should I wait for you to edit it when you make yourself look stupid again?

You're going to talk about someone making themselves look stupid?

Not shocking, as you didn't have a better response.

You do make yourself look stupid, time and time again. You always try to blame it on others (like: "Mack's just mad cause...") but in reality, you're the one that makes yourself look like a giant tool time and time again. It's the reason why you get banned all the time, and then you bitch about that too. You love to start problems and then when you make yourself look like a dumbass, you try to blame someone else. You're exactly like Dead.

At this point, you know you're wrong so instead of going after my argument, you attack me personally. That's typical of idiots that know they're wrong but can't admit it because their ego is too fucking big. All you do is Ad hominem when you're backed up into a corner and don't know what to say. You admitted you know like 8 quarterbacks. So stop doubling down on your picks and admit they're worthless. They're garbage and stop acting like a fucking idiot. The funny part is that your comment applies to you. * Admits ignorance makes dumbass picks* then bitches "If anyone disagrees with me they're so hostile" and when someone calls you out on your stupidity, you compare them to Dead. You're the one that started this by bitching us out, now grow some balls and deal with it.

Quit making yourself look foolish. It's so obvious to anyone that sees this that you've lost this argument. So you can continue to grow your own ego by talking to yourself if you feel like. It won't change the fact your picks are fucking stupid and you don't know shit about football. Goodbye.

Well, you're not wrong about one part. I don't know all that much about football, because I don't take the time to care. But you and your buddies are the ones that made this into a big strict thing. When Burdur posted this, it looked like a friendly opinion post. I felt I should make more posts, including one here. I saw that this thread was open, I read the rules in the first post, and I made my picks. I gave my honest opinions about those I DID know about (Brees, Romo, Flacco, RG3, Kaepernick, Roethlesberger, Eli and Peyton Manning, and of course Michael Vick... among a few others), and those I didn't know much about, I read the picks before me, including yours, to get the general consensus of where they stood.

Now, it was just a friendly opinionated post, a friendly opinionated thread that Burdur made to get "XWA's top 200 NFL Players" and yet you all get butthurt when I - following the rules - made picks that you don't like. Who cares if I gave Vick a 0? I think he sucks. It's my opinion. And according to this last season, a fact. Isn't that what the thread was made for in the first place? But no, then you and your little group decided to make this a "you" thing and suddenly it wasn't about opinions. Hell, like I said earlier, if this wasn't going to be a thread about your picks and your opinions, then why even bother making a thread? Just make a list of people you want, don't even bother getting anyone's opinion. Or hell, like Drachen said, just PM the 5 people that "know so much about football" on XWA and don't even bother to ask anyone else.

This is a retarded idea for a topic because of what it was made into. But what should I expect from you idiots that take shit like this insanely seriously? I gave Vick a 0, which is well within the rules, and you all got butthurt because it "threw the system off", then it's a stupid system. If I can make a pick within the rules and throw the system off, then your system and your rules are retarded. You know damn well this was just going to be a circle jerk between this little group and no one else was allowed to really make any picks. So fuck you, go be a little bitch somewhere else then. Just don't cry when you get banned and no one gives a shit again.

Señor Drächen wrote:

Ian wrote:

Damn I missed some shit.

but RGIII's rookie season was worthy of a 9 at least. One of the best rookie seasons of all time. Saying he hasn't done dick is patently false. He was not good last year, but he did already carry an awful team into the postseason.

65.6% completion percentage. 27 TDs/7 TOs, 4015 total Yards. Carried awful team to playoffs.

Mexi tell him he got a spirm computer

Bro, if you give RG3 a 9 you'd have to give Andrew Luck a 10.

I'm not saying he deserves a 9 today. I'm saying if you're only judging one season without future projections he was a 9. Mexi said he never did dick, but his rookie season he was a top 5 QB in the NFL. I think I gave him a 7.5 as far as where I expect him to be this year. I'm lying cause I expect him to ball out and deserve another 9 but I don't wanna seem stupid.

I'd give his rookie season a solid 7.5-8. Same w/ Luck.