WTF Burdur

I'll update this in a few days.

Tomorrow I'll be adding 2 lists.

The TE/FB list and OLine & DLine combined list.

Fixed the first 2 posts in this thread to make it look a little more neat and organized.


And I'll be trying to post the next list or two at some point tonight.

Ugh, so unmotivated to get the next lists with the declining interest in this (and not many ratings to even begin with). I'm gonna force myself through it to get this finished, though. I'll get this going again soon and then try to at least get 1 list posted a week once I do.

Alright now that the WWE Superstars version of this is complete (which you can find the results here if interested: https://xwauniverse.forumotion.com/t16584-xwa-s-current-top-50-wwe-superstars-the-official-list), I'm ready and willing to continue doing this.

However, I'd rather not waste time doing it if we have like 3 people at most giving ratings each time.

So post here if you're interested in giving ratings (and will legitimately try not to miss/skip any positions). If it's at least about 5 people, I'll get this going again. And btw if anyone's just seeing this or just now wanting to take part, you can find links the offensive positions on the 2nd post of this thread and it's still possible to give your ratings for the ones you've missed.

Somebody tell me what NFL players retired in 2009 so I can give them 10 .

No one?


I might just get the results for the offensive players one of these days and change this to a top 100-150 offensive NFL players list (skill positions only). Since all the offensive positions are done and so this doesn't go to complete waste.

Ok, this is now an Offense Only list of 100 players, and the list is now complete but will be revealed in parts.

For now, the Not Top 100:

Trent Richardson 6.90 RB
Owen Daniels 6.88 TE
Zach Miller 6.88 TE
Joique Bell 6.83 RB
Knowshon Moreno 6.83 RB
Alex Smith 6.80 QB
Golden Tate 6.80 WR
Hakeem Nicks 6.80 WR
Jermaine Gresham 6.75 TE
Jermichael Finley 6.75 TE
Toby Gerhart 6.75 RB
Justin Blackmon 6.70 WR
Darren Sproles 6.67 RB
Brent Celek 6.63 TE
Rashad Jennings 6.60 RB
Terrance Williams 6.60 WR
Ben Tate 6.58 RB
DeAngelo Williams 6.58 RB
Steven Jackson 6.58 RB
Andre Ellington 6.50 RB
Brian Hartline 6.50 WR
Cecil Shorts III 6.50 WR
Greg Jones 6.50 FB
Jed Collins 6.50 FB
Santonio Holmes 6.50 WR
Scott Chandler 6.50 TE
Stevan Ridley 6.50 RB
Stevie Johnson 6.50 WR
Ahmad Bradshaw 6.40 RB
DeAndre Hopkins 6.40 WR
Greg Jennings 6.40 WR
Joe Flacco 6.40 QB
Ryan Tannehill 6.40 QB
Rueben Randle 6.38 WR
Darren McFadden 6.33 RB
Montee Ball 6.33 RB
Pierre Thomas 6.33 RB
Brandon Pettigrew 6.25 TE
Chris Ivory 6.25 RB
Garrett Graham 6.25 TE
Tim Wright 6.25 TE
Doug Baldwin 6.20 WR
Donald Brown 6.10 RB
Jake Locker 6.10 QB
Miles Austin 6.10 WR
Nate Washington 6.10 WR
Roy Helu 6.10 RB
Shonn Greene 6.10 RB
Danny Woodhead 6.08 RB
Andy Dalton 6.00 QB
Darrel Young 6.00 FB
Denarius Moore 6.00 WR
Eli Manning 6.00 QB
Emmanuel Sanders 6.00 WR
Mychal Rivera 6.00 TE
Lamar Miller 5.92 RB
LeGarrette Blount 5.92 RB
Shane Vereen 5.92 RB
Carson Palmer 5.90 QB
Danny Amendola 5.90 WR
James Jones 5.90 WR
Lance Moore 5.90 WR
Marvin Jones 5.80 WR
Sam Bradford 5.80 QB
Bernard Pierce 5.75 RB
Joseph Fauria 5.75 TE
Kenny Britt 5.75 WR
Rob Housler 5.75 TE
Kenny Stills 5.70 WR
Marlon Brown 5.70 WR
Mike Williams 5.70 WR
Rod Streater 5.70 WR
Josh McCown 5.60 QB
Mike Glennon 5.60 QB
Jonathan Stewart 5.58 RB
Aaron Dobson 5.50 WR
Anthony Fasano 5.50 TE
Brandon Myers 5.50 TE
Mark Sanchez 5.50 QB
Michael Vick 5.50 QB
BenJarvus Green-Ellis 5.42 RB
Mark Ingram 5.42 RB
Jeremy Kerley 5.40 WR
Matt Schaub 5.30 QB
Ryan Fitzpatrick 5.13 QB
Bilal Powell 5.10 RB
Geno Smith 5.10 QB
Harry Douglas 5.10 WR
EJ Manuel 5.00 QB
Jerome Simpson 5.00 WR
Peyton Hillis 5.00 RB
Andre Brown 4.92 RB
Kyle Orton 4.75 QB
Jarret Boykin 4.70 WR
Josh Freeman 4.70 QB
Matt Cassel 4.20 QB
Chad Henne 4.00 QB
Jason Campbell 4.00 QB
James Starks 3.92 RB
Christian Ponder 3.70 QB

A couple people got robbed IMO, but overall pretty much what I'd expect of the list not in the top 100.

16 QB's, 21 RB's, 7 FB's, 35 WR's, and 21 TE's have made the list.


There are A LOT of ties, multiple 4 to 5-way ties... I blame the small amount of people giving ratings. Also should've probably went with ratings by .25 like the WWE list.

#100
Chris Johnson
Final Rating: 6.92
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 6
New York Jets
21st Ranked RB

There's a teaser showing the first on the list. CJ2K


Since there's so many ties in this, I just realized I'll rank them with some tie-breakers. First tie-breaker is highest rating given to the player, second is how many of that rating were given.

#100
Chris Johnson
Final Rating: 6.92
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 6
New York Jets
21st Ranked RB



#99
Martellus Bennett
Final Rating: 7.00
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 6.5
Chicago Bears
21st Ranked TE



#98
Maurice Jones-Drew
Final Rating: 7.00
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 5
Oakland Raiders
20th Ranked RB



#97
Mike Wallace
Final Rating: 7.00
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6
Miami Dolphins
35th Ranked WR



#96
Fred Jackson
Final Rating: 7.08
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 7
Buffalo Bills
19th Ranked RB



#95
Eric Decker
Final Rating: 7.10
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6
New York Jets
34th Ranked WR



#94
Dwayne Bowe
Final Rating: 7.10
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6
Kansas City Chiefs
33rd Ranked WR



#93
Cordarelle Patterson
Final Rating: 7.10
Highest Rating: 8.5
Lowest Rating: 6
Minnesota Vikings
32nd Ranked WR



#92
Marcedes Lewis
Final Rating: 7.13
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 6.5
Jacksonville Jaguars
20th Ranked TE



#91
Jared Cook
Final Rating: 7.13
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6.5
St. Louis Rams
19th Ranked TE

Judging from our first ten, we did a worse job then the WWE people

Decker should be way higher than he is.

#90
Ladarius Green
Final Rating: 7.13
Highest Rating: 8.5
Lowest Rating: 6
San Diego Chargers
18th Ranked TE



#89
Riley Cooper
Final Rating: 7.20
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 7
Philadelphia Eagles
31st Ranked WR



#88
Robert Griffin III
Final Rating: 7.20
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 6.5
Washington Redskins
16th Ranked QB



#87
Steve Smith
Final Rating: 7.20
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6
Baltimore Ravens
30th Ranked WR



#86
Michael Floyd
Final Rating: 7.20
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 5.5
Arizona Cardinals
29th Ranked WR



#85
Jay Cutler
Final Rating: 7.30
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
Chicago Bears
15th Ranked QB



#84
Colin Kaepernick
Final Rating: 7.30
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
San Francisco 49ers
14th Ranked QB



#83
Torrey Smith
Final Rating: 7.30
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6.5
Baltimore Ravens
28th Ranked WR



#82
Julian Edelman
Final Rating: 7.30
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6
New England Patriots
27th Ranked WR



#81
Reggie Bush
Final Rating: 7.33
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 7
Detroit Lions
18th Ranked RB

Biggest ... Cooper higher on the list than Decker.


Kaep & RG3 going a little too early too IMO.

How is Reggie Bush on the list?

#80
Zach Ertz
Final Rating: 7.38
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 7
Philadelphia Eagles
17th Ranked TE



#79
Heath Miller
Final Rating: 7.38
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 7
Pittsburgh Steelers
16th Ranked TE



#78
Coby Fleener
Final Rating: 7.38
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 7
Indianapolis Colts
15th Ranked TE



#77
Michael Robinson
Final Rating: 7.38
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
Seattle Seahawks (Now Retired)
7th Ranked FB



#76
Charles Clay
Final Rating: 7.38
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
Miami Dolphins
14th Ranked TE



#75
Delanie Walker
Final Rating: 7.38
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6
Tennessee Titans
13th Ranked TE



#74
Ben Roethlisberger
Final Rating: 7.40
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
Pittsburgh Steelers
13th Ranked QB



#73
Anquan Boldin
Final Rating: 7.40
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
San Francisco 49ers
26th Ranked WR



#72
Nick Foles
Final Rating: 7.40
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6.5
Philadelphia Eagles
12th Ranked QB



#71
Kendall Wright
Final Rating: 7.40
Highest Rating: 8.5
Lowest Rating: 6.5
Tennessee Titans
25th Ranked WR

#70
C.J. Spiller
Final Rating: 7.42
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
Buffalo Bills
17th Ranked RB



#69
Russell Wilson
Final Rating: 7.50
Highest Rating: 7.5
Lowest Rating: 7.5
Seattle Seahawks
11th Ranked QB



#68
Vonta Leach
Final Rating: 7.50
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
Baltimore Ravens (Now a Free Agent)
6th Ranked FB



#67
Tyler Eifert
Final Rating: 7.50
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
Cincinnati Bengals
12th Ranked TE



#66
Marques Colston
Final Rating: 7.50
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
New Orleans Saints
24th Ranked WR



#65
John Conner
Final Rating: 7.50
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6.5
New York Jets
5th Ranked FB



#64
Ryan Mathews
Final Rating: 7.58
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7.5
San Diego Chargers
16th Ranked RB



#63
LeVeon Bell
Final Rating: 7.58
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 7
Pittsburgh Steelers
15th Ranked RB



#62
Ray Rice
Final Rating: 7.58
Highest Rating: 8
Lowest Rating: 6.5
Baltimore Ravens (Now Suspended)
14th Ranked RB



#61
Giovani Bernard
Final Rating: 7.58
Highest Rating: 8.5
Lowest Rating: 7
Cincinnati Bengals
13th Ranked RB

I'm gonna finish posting these during winter break btw, which starts around the middle of December for me.

I'd just copy/paste the rest of the list but after already doing 40 of them I might as well finish this the right way.

Might as well just finalize this list. Sooooooo many people either highly under-rated or over-rated.

Full results are on the first page. Here are the top 60 that haven't been announced yet until now:

1. Adrian Peterson (MIN): 9.92 - RB1
2. Calvin Johnson (DET): 9.90 - WR1
3. LeSean McCoy (PHI): 9.83 - RB2
4. Peyton Manning (DEN): 9.80 - QB1
5. Jimmy Graham (NO): 9.75 - TE1
6. Drew Brees (NO): 9.60 - QB2
7. Aaron Rodgers (GB): 9.50 - QB3
8. Jamaal Charles (KC): 9.42 - RB3
9. Dez Bryant (DAL): 9.40 - WR2
10. A.J. Green (CIN): 9.30 - WR3
11. Tom Brady (NE): 9.20 - QB4
12. Rob Gronkowski (NE): 9.13 - TE2
13. Josh Gordon (CLE): 9.10 - WR4
14. Marshawn Lynch (SEA): 9.00 - RB4
15. Brandon Marshall (CHI): 9.00 - WR5
16. Matt Forte (CHI): 8.83 - RB5
17. Julio Jones (ATL): 8.80 - WR6
18. Jason Witten (DAL): 8.75 - TE3
19. Julius Thomas (DEN): 8.75 - TE4
20. Demaryius Thomas (DEN): 8.70 - WR7
21. Vernon Davis (SF): 8.63 - TE5
22. Jordan Cameron (CLE): 8.63 - TE6
23. Vincent Jackson (TB): 8.60 - WR8
24. Andre Johnson (HOU): 8.60 - WR9
25. Alshon Jeffery (CHI): 8.50 - WR10
26. Larry Fitzgerald (ARI): 8.50 - WR11
27. Kyle Rudolph (MIN): 8.38 - TE7
28. Arian Foster (HOU): 8.25 - RB6
29. Jordy Nelson (GB): 8.20 - WR12
30. Philip Rivers (SD): 8.20 - QB5
31. Victor Cruz (NYG): 8.20 - WR13
32. Alfred Morris (WAS): 8.17 - RB7
33. Eddie Lacy (GB): 8.17 - RB8
34. Mike Tolbert (CAR): 8.13 - FB1
35. Marcel Reece (OAK): 8.13 - FB2
36. Pierre Garcon (WAS): 8.10 - WR14
37. Andrew Luck (IND): 8.10 - QB6
38. Matthew Stafford (DET): 8.10 - QB7
39. Wes Welker (DEN): 8.10 - WR15
40. T.Y. Hilton (IND): 8.00 - WR16
41. Reggie Wayne (IND): 8.00 - WR17
42. DeMarco Murray (DAL): 7.92 - RB9
43. Antonio Brown (PIT): 7.90 - WR18
44. Cam Newton (CAR): 7.90 - QB8
45. Michael Crabtree (SF): 7.90 - WR19
46. Dennis Pitta (BAL): 7.88 - TE8
47. Frank Gore (SF): 7.83 - RB10
48. Randall Cobb (GB): 7.80 - WR20
49. Roddy White (ATL): 7.80 - WR21
50. DeSean Jackson (WAS): 7.80 - WR22
51. Doug Martin (TB): 7.75 - RB11
52. Zac Stacy (STL): 7.75 - RB12
53. Jerome Felton (MIN): 7.75 - FB3
54. Greg Olsen (CHI): 7.75 - TE9
55. Matt Ryan (ATL): 7.70 - QB9
56. John Kuhn (GB): 7.63 - FB4
57. Antonio Gates (SD): 7.63 - TE10
58. Jordan Reed (WAS): 7.63 - TE11
59. Keenan Allen (SD): 7.60 - WR23
60. Tony Romo (DAL): 7.60 - QB10

Mike Tolbert over Tony Romo

WTF on a sandwich.