Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30: Give Your Ratings!

Icon Posts : 17002 Join date : 2013-07-23

The way this works is you will give each superstar a rating from 1-10 (half ratings and quarter ratings allowed but no other decimal ratings). I decided this will be judged on one rating for each superstar (rather than categories) but the categories can help you decide what you want that rating to be.

Ring Work / Mic Skills / Drawing Ability / Consistency / Storytelling

Use any or all of these categories as a basis to judge the superstars on. If you want you could even give a rating for each individual category if you're willing to get the averages yourself but in your post you must only give one number rating next to each superstar's name. You can consider certain aspects to be more important than others, in the end it's just your opinion.

Remember, make sure to base your ratings solely on how good (or bad) you think each superstar has been since WrestleMania 30. Quality > Quantity so it doesn't really matter how much longer someone's been on the main roster unless that extra time has helped proven someone more in your eyes.

After a couple weeks, I'll average out the scores and make a list for the top 50.

Here is the list of eligible current superstars:

Superstars who have just had one-off matches or have only made a few (or one) small appearances in the ring since WM 30 will not be included (examples: Shane McMahon, Eva Marie, Lana).

NXT Superstars will not be included. If someone's time in NXT (since WM30) helps you form an opinion on them for your rating then that's fine.

Aiden English
AJ Styles
Alberto Del Rio
Alicia Fox
Apollo Crews
Baron Corbin
Becky Lynch
Big Cass
Big E
Big Show
Bo Dallas
Braun Strowman
Bray Wyatt
Brie Bella
Brock Lesnar
Bubba Ray Dudley
Cesaro
Charlotte
Chris Jericho
Curtis Axel
D-Von Dudley
Dana Brooke
Darren Young
Dean Ambrose
Dolph Ziggler
Emma
Enzo Amore
Epico
Erick Rowan
Fandango
Goldust
Heath Slater
Jack Swagger
Jey Uso
Jimmy Uso
John Cena
Kalisto
Kane
Karl Anderson
Kevin Owens
Kofi Kingston
Konnor
Luke Gallows
Luke Harper
Mark Henry
Naomi
Natalya
Neville
Nikki Bella
Paige
Primo
R-Truth
Randy Orton
Roman Reigns
Rosa Mendes
Rusev
Ryback
Sami Zayn
Sasha Banks
Seth Rollins
Sheamus
Simon Gotch
Sin Cara
Summer Rae
Tamina
The Miz
Titus O'Neil
Triple H
Tyler Breeze
Tyson Kidd
Undertaker
Viktor
Xavier Woods
Zack Ryder

Aiden English - 6.5
AJ Styles - 9
Alberto Del Rio - 7
Alicia Fox - 6
Apollo Crews - 7.5
Baron Corbin - 6
Becky Lynch - 7.5
Big Cass - 7
Big E - 8.5
Big Show - 5.5
Bo Dallas - 6.5
Braun Strowman - 4
Bray Wyatt - 9
Brie Bella - 6.5
Brock Lesnar - 9
Bubba Ray Dudley - 6.5
Cesaro - 8.5
Charlotte - 7
Chris Jericho - 8.5
Curtis Axel - 6
D-Von Dudley - 5
Dana Brooke - 5.5
Darren Young - 5.5
Dean Ambrose - 8.5
Dolph Ziggler - 8
Emma - 8 (7.75 if quarter ratings are allowed)
Enzo Amore - 7.5
Epico - 6.5
Erick Rowan - 6.5
Fandango - 5
Goldust - 5.5
Heath Slater - 6
Jack Swagger - 5
Jey Uso - 7
Jimmy Uso - 7
John Cena - 9.5
Kalisto - 7.5
Kane - 6.5
Karl Anderson - 7
Kevin Owens - 10
Kofi Kingston - 8
Konnor - 3.5
Luke Gallows - 7
Luke Harper - 8
Mark Henry - 6.5
Naomi - 6.5
Natalya - 7
Neville - 8
Nikki Bella - 7.5
Paige - 7.5
Primo - 6.5
R-Truth - 7
Randy Orton - 7.5
Roman Reigns - 7.5
Rosa Mendes - 2
Rusev - 9
Ryback - 7
Sami Zayn - 9
Sasha Banks - 9
Seth Rollins - 10
Sheamus - 8
Simon Gotch - 7
Sin Cara - 7
Summer Rae - 5.5
Tamina - 4.5
The Miz - 8
Titus O'Neil - 5.5
Triple H - 8.5
Tyler Breeze - 7.5
Tyson Kidd - 8
Undertaker - 8.5
Viktor - 3.5
Xavier Woods - 8
Zack Ryder - 5

Guest

Aiden English- 6.5
AJ Styles- 8.5
Alberto Del Rio- 7.5
Alicia Fox- 4
Apollo Crews- 7
Baron Corbin- 7
Becky Lynch- 6.5
Big Cass- 7
Big E- 7.5
Big Show- 6.5
Bo Dallas- 5
Braun Strowman- 5
Bray Wyatt- 8.5
Brie Bella- 3.5
Brock Lesnar- 8
Bubba Ray Dudley- 6.5
Cesaro- 9
Charlotte- 6
Chris Jericho- 7.5
Curtis Axel- 4
D-Von Dudley- 6
Dana Brooke- 3.5
Darren Young- 5
Dean Ambrose- 7.5
Dolph Ziggler- 7
Emma- 2
Enzo Amore- 7.5
Epico- 5
Erick Rowan- 5.5
Fandango- 5
Goldust- 7.5
Heath Slater- 4
Jack Swagger- 5.5
Jey Uso- 6.5
Jimmy Uso- 6.5
John Cena- 9
Kalisto- 6
Kane- 6.5
Karl Anderson- 6.5
Kevin Owens- 9
Kofi Kingston- 7
Konnor- 4.5
Luke Gallows- 6.5
Luke Harper- 7.5
Mark Henry- 7
Naomi- 6
Natalya- 6.5
Neville- 7
Nikki Bella- 5.5
Paige- 6.5
Primo- 4
R-Truth-5
Randy Orton- 7.5
Roman Reigns- 7.5
Rosa Mendes- 2
Rusev- 7
Ryback- 7
Sami Zayn- 7.5
Sasha Banks- 7
Seth Rollins- 9
Sheamus- 7
Simon Gotch- 6.5
Sin Cara- 6
Summer Rae- 3.5
Tamina- 5.5
The Miz- 8
Titus O'Neil- 7
Triple H- 8
Tyler Breeze- 5.5
Tyson Kidd- 7
Undertaker- 10
Viktor- 5.5
Xavier Woods- 7.5
Zack Ryder- 6.5

TeamMoose Posts : 14180 Join date : 2013-07-19 Age : 31

Based only on what they've done in WWE since WM30:

Aiden English 4.75
AJ Styles 9.0
Alberto Del Rio 7.5
Alicia Fox 3.25
Apollo Crews 5.5
Baron Corbin 5.0
Becky Lynch 6.5
Big Cass 6.25
Big E 7.75
Big Show 6.5
Bo Dallas 5.75
Braun Strowman 1.5
Bray Wyatt 8.75
Brie Bella 3.0
Brock Lesnar 9.0
Bubba Ray Dudley 5.75
Cesaro 7.25
Charlotte 6.25
Chris Jericho 8.75
Curtis Axel 3.75
D-Von Dudley 5.5
Dana Brooke 3.5
Darren Young 4.75
Dean Ambrose 8.75
Dolph Ziggler 7.75
Emma 5.0
Enzo Amore 6.5
Epico 3.75
Erick Rowan 3.0
Fandango 4.25
Goldust 4.75
Heath Slater 5.75
Jack Swagger 4.0
Jey Uso 7.0
Jimmy Uso 7.0
John Cena 9.75
Kalisto 6.5
Kane 7.0
Karl Anderson 4.75
Kevin Owens 8.75
Kofi Kingston 7.0
Konnor 0.
Luke Gallows 4.75
Luke Harper 7.0
Mark Henry 5.5
Naomi 3.75
Natalya 4.75
Neville 7.25
Nikki Bella 6.5
Paige 6.0
Primo 3.75
R-Truth 5.75
Randy Orton 8.5
Roman Reigns 8.5
Rosa Mendes 0.
Rusev 8.75
Ryback 6.0
Sami Zayn 7.75
Sasha Banks 8.0
Seth Rollins 9.5
Sheamus 7.75
Simon Gotch 6.0
Sin Cara 5.5
Summer Rae 4.75
Tamina 3.25
The Miz 7.25
Titus O'Neil 3.5
Triple H 8.5
Tyler Breeze 6.5
Tyson Kidd 7.25
Undertaker 7.75
Viktor 5.0
Xavier Woods 6.0
Zack Ryder 5.75

Icon Posts : 17002 Join date : 2013-07-23

3 people so far is more than I was expecting. I aint bothered

Hopefully there's still plenty more though.

Aiden English - 5
AJ Styles - 9
Alberto Del Rio - 7.25
Alicia Fox - 4
Apollo Crews - 5.5
Baron Corbin - 5.5
Becky Lynch - 6.25
Big Cass - 6
Big E - 7.75
Big Show - 6.25
Bo Dallas - 6
Braun Strowman - 4.5
Bray Wyatt - 9
Brie Bella - 4.25
Brock Lesnar - 9.75
Bubba Ray Dudley - 6.75
Cesaro - 8
Charlotte - 6.25
Chris Jericho - 8.25
Curtis Axel - 5
D-Von Dudley - 6
Dana Brooke - 3
Darren Young - 5.75
Dean Ambrose - 9
Dolph Ziggler - 8.5
Emma - 5
Enzo Amore - 7.25
Epico - 3
Erick Rowan - 5
Fandango - 4
Goldust - 5
Heath Slater - 6.75
Jack Swagger - 6
Jey Uso - 6.25
Jimmy Uso - 6.25
John Cena - 9
Kalisto - 6.5
Kane - 7
Karl Anderson - 6.75
Kevin Owens - 9.5
Kofi Kingston - 8
Konnor - 3
Luke Gallows - 6.75
Luke Harper - 7.25
Mark Henry - 5.5
Naomi - 4.5
Natalya - 5
Neville - 6.75
Nikki Bella - 6.75
Paige - 6.5
Primo - 3.25
R-Truth - 7.25
Randy Orton - 8.25
Roman Reigns - 8
Rosa Mendes - 1
Rusev - 7.5
Ryback - 7
Sami Zayn - 7.5
Sasha Banks - 8.25
Seth Rollins - 10
Sheamus - 7
Simon Gotch - 5.25
Sin Cara - 4.5
Summer Rae - 3.5
Tamina - 2.5
The Miz - 8.25
Titus O'Neil - 5.5
Triple H - 8.75
Tyler Breeze - 5
Tyson Kidd - 7
Undertaker - 8
Viktor - 3
Xavier Woods - 8
Zack Ryder - 5

Icon Posts : 17002 Join date : 2013-07-23

Bump for more ratings.

AJ Styles - 10
Alberto Del Rio - 9
Alicia Fox - 3
Baron Corbin - 4
Becky Lynch - 7
Big E - 8
Big Show - 6
Bo Dallas - 3
Braun Strowman - 0
Bray Wyatt - 7
Brie Bella - 1
Brock Lesnar - 8
Bubba Ray Dudley- 8
Cesaro - 9
Charlotte - 7
Chris Jericho - 7
Curtis Axel - 6
D-Von Dudley - 6
Darren Young - 3
Dean Ambrose - 7
Dolph Ziggler - 8
Emma - 7
Enzo Amore - 7
Epico - 6
Erick Rowan - 2
Fandango - 4
Goldust - 6
Heath Slater - 5
Jack Swagger - 6
Jey Uso - 6
Jimmy Uso - 6
John Cena - 10
Kalisto - 7
Kane - 5
Karl Anderson - 9
Kevin Owens - 10
Kofi Kingston - 8
Konnor - 2
Luke Gallows - 9
Luke Harper - 9
Mark Henry - 7
Naomi - 3
Natalya - 8
Neville - 8
Nikki Bella - 1
Paige - 7
Primo - 5
R-Truth - 6
Randy Orton - 8
Roman Reigns - 7
Rosa Mendes - 2
Rusev - 8
Ryback - 7
Sami Zayn - 9
Sasha Banks - 9
Seth Rollins - 10
Sheamus - 7
Sin Cara - 6
Summer Rae - 2
Tamina - 2
The Miz - 6
Titus O'Neil - 5
Triple H - 3
Tyler Breeze - 6
Tyson Kidd - 7
Undertaker - 8
Viktor - 6
Xavier Woods - 7
Zack Ryder - 6