All superstars will be rated from 1-10 (quarter ratings allowed) & based on only recent years (no later than 2010). This has nothing to do with how they've been booked (main event, midcard, etc.) or any title reigns. Base your ratings on their entire skillset; the total package: in the ring, on mic, their ability to draw a crowd, their charisma, their overall entertainment factor, etc.


Roman Reigns
Rosa Mendes
Rusev
Ryback
Santino Marella
Seth Rollins
Sheamus
Sin Cara
Summer Rae
Tamina Snuka
Tensai
Titus O'Neil
Triple H
Tyson Kidd
Undertaker
Wade Barrett
William Regal
Xavier Woods
Yoshi Tatsu
Zack Ryder

Roman Reigns - 9.25/10
Rosa Mendes - 5/10
Rusev - 7.25/10
Ryback - 8/10
Santino Marella - 7.5/10
Seth Rollins - 9.75/10
Sheamus - 8.5/10
Sin Cara - 5.25/10
Summer Rae - 5/10
Tamina Snuka - 6/10
Tensai - 6/10
Titus O'Neil - 7/10
Triple H - 10/10
Tyson Kidd - 6.25/10
Undertaker - 8.5/10
Wade Barrett - 8/10
William Regal - 7.5/10
Xavier Woods - 6.5/10
Yoshi Tatsu - 5.5/10
Zack Ryder - 6.75/10

Roman Reigns- 7.5/10
Rosa Mendes- 3/10
Rusev- 5/10
Ryback- 7.5/10
Santino Marella- 6.5/10
Seth Rollins- 7.5
Sheamus- 8/10
Sin Cara- 4/10
Summer Rae- 4/10
Tamina Snuka- 5/10
Tensai- 5/10
Titus O'Neil- 5.5/10
Triple H- 9.5/10
Tyson Kidd- 5/10
Undertaker- 10/10
Wade Barrett- 7/10
William Regal- 6/10
Xavier Woods- 5/10
Yoshi Tatsu- 4/10
Zack Ryder- 6/10

Roman Reigns - 9
Rosa Mendes - 2
Rusev - 6.5
Ryback - 6
Santino Marella - 1
Seth Rollins - 10
Sheamus - 7.5
Sin Cara - 6
Summer Rae - 3
Tamina Snuka - 4
Tensai - 3.5
Titus O'Neil - 4
Triple H - 10
Tyson Kidd - 3.5
Undertaker - 10
Wade Barrett - 9
William Regal - 4
Xavier Woods - 4
Yoshi Tatsu - 3.5
Zack Ryder - 5.5

Roman Reigns - 7/10
Rosa Mendes - 2/10
Rusev - 4/10
Ryback - 5/10
Santino Marella - 5.5/10
Seth Rollins - 7.5/10
Sheamus - 7.5/10
Sin Cara - 6/10
Summer Rae - 4/10
Tamina Snuka - 3/10
Tensai - 4/10
Titus O'Neil - 5.5/10
Triple H - 8/10
Tyson Kidd - 6.5/10
Undertaker - 10/10
Wade Barrett - 7/10
William Regal - 8/10
Xavier Woods - 5/10
Yoshi Tatsu - 4/10
Zack Ryder - 4/10

Roman Reigns - 8/10
Rosa Mendes - 1/10
Rusev - 2/10
Ryback - 6.5/10
Santino Marella - 5.5/10
Seth Rollins - 8.5/10
Sheamus - 7/10
Sin Cara - 4.5/10
Summer Rae - 1/10
Tamina Snuka - 2/10
Tensai - 5.5/10
Titus O'Neil - 6/10
Triple H - 7.5/10
Tyson Kidd - 6/10
Undertaker - 3.5/10 (Emphais on 'Since 2010'. The last match of his I enjoyed was in 2009)
Wade Barrett - 7.5/10
William Regal - 5.5/10
Xavier Woods - 4/10
Yoshi Tatsu - 3/10
Zack Ryder - 5/10

TJ wrote:

Undertaker - 3.5/10 (Emphais on 'Since 2010'. The last match of his I enjoyed was in 2009)

Half the pillocks on here gave Rock 10/10 for his work after 2010 (a few terrible matches and some awful promos), so I think we're ignoring the "since 2010" thing.

I just went back and looked...he's right.

Y'all stupid.

You're an idiot. Thankfully I believe Burdur is ignoring outliers. And this is the same person that bitched at me for giving Vick a low score.

I knew you'd bring that up. I didn't like your score because you gave it to him for off-field stuff. My score for Taker was PURELY on in-ring performance in the last 4 years, which I honestly believe was garbage.

I didn't give it to him for (purely) off-field stuff. I gave it to him based off his last, horrendous year. Also, before Burdur edited it, he wrote "1 - give this score if you think they'll be out of the league in the next few years." which I honestly believe is going to happen to Vick if he continues his shitty run like last year.

That said, you gave Undertaker a lower score than Sin Cara, Zack Ryder, and only .5 away from being on-par with Yoshi Tatsu. Taking into account that I know you don't like the Undertaker, that's super fucking ridiculous.

It doesn't really matter though, as Burdur said he's ignoring outliers and I don't think anyone else is so spiteful of Taker they'd give him that much of a ridiculous score.

I don't 'not like' him. I think he's one of the best wrestlers of all time. I just think he should have retired five years ago.

Wasn't his 2nd match with Shawn in 2010?

If Rock is allowed to get 10/10, Undertaker should be allowed to get 4/10.

Hell, Kelly Kelly should be allowed to get 17/10 if Rock gets anything above a 6.

Yes, and while it was clearly the best of his matches in the timeframe we're talking about, I don't think it should have happened. If anyone, he should have faced Jericho that year.

I agree, but it was an excellent match nonetheless. That alone should put him WAY above Yoshi fuckin' Tatsu and Zack Ryder.


^^ Oh, you hush. At least Rock's matches with Punk were excellent.

I think Ryder's unique way of getting himself over merits a good score, honestly.

Roman Reigns - 7/10
Rosa Mendes - 1/10
Rusev - 3/10
Ryback - 5/10
Santino Marella - 6/10
Seth Rollins - 7/10
Sheamus - 8/10
Sin Cara - 3.5/10
Summer Rae - 2/10
Tamina Snuka - 2.5/10
Tensai - 4/10
Titus O'Neil - 5/10
Triple H - 6/10 (2010?)
Tyson Kidd - 5/10
Undertaker - 8/10
Wade Barrett - 7.5/10
William Regal - 7/10 (Commentary 10/10)
Xavier Woods - 5/10
Yoshi Tatsu - 3/10
Zack Ryder - 10/10

Razor wrote:

^^ Oh, you hush. At least Rock's matches with Punk were excellent.

Be quiet, Cameron.

Mink whyyyy.

This is what you're turning me into, Razor.

I don't know how much more either of us can take.

And this IS since 2010. If it wasn't I think he's definitely a 10. I personally gave him an 8.5, which to me is more reasonable for him recently. 4.5 is pretty damn ridiculous/harsh but I guess I could see an argument for it at his age and rare appearances / matches the past couple years. Either way if it's an outlier it won't count anyway.

Meth wrote:

Santino Marella - 20/10

Real rating or his rating doesn't count.

Burdur Obama wrote:

And this IS since 2010. If it wasn't I think he's definitely a 10. I personally gave him an 8.5, which to me is more reasonable for him recently. 4.5 is pretty damn ridiculous/harsh but I guess I could see an argument for it at his age and rare appearances / matches the past couple years. Either way if it's an outlier it won't count anyway.

Meth wrote:

Santino Marella - 20/10

Real rating or his rating doesn't count.

Fine I edited it to a real rating.
Despite being an outlier I'm not changing Ryder's rating

Roman Reigns 10/10
Rosa Mendes 1/10
Rusev 5/10
Ryback 8/10
Santino Marella 6/10
Seth Rollins 10/10
Sheamus 8.5/10
Sin Cara 5/10
Summer Rae 3/10
Tamina Snuka 5.5/10
Tensai 4.5/10
Titus O'Neil 7.5/10
Triple H 9.5/10
Tyson Kidd 5/10
Undertaker 10/10
Wade Barrett 8.5/10
William Regal 7.5/10
Xavier Woods 6/10
Yoshi Tatsu 4/10
Zack Ryder 6.5/10