All superstars will be rated from 1-10 (quarter ratings allowed) & based on only recent years (no later than 2010). This has nothing to do with how they've been booked (main event, midcard, etc.) or any title reigns. Base your ratings on their entire skillset; the total package: in the ring, on mic, their ability to draw a crowd, their charisma, their overall entertainment factor, etc.


Here is the first set of WWE superstars:

Adam Rose
AJ Lee
Aksana
Alberto Del Rio
Alex Riley
Alicia Fox
Big E
Big Show
Bo Dallas
Bray Wyatt
Brie Bella
Brock Lesnar
Brodus Clay
Cameron
Cesaro
Chris Jericho
Christian
Cody Rhodes
Curt Hawkins
Curtis Axel


Discussion is allowed, but no going too off topic.

Adam Rose - 4.5/10
AJ Lee - 8.25/10
Aksana - 4/10
Alberto Del Rio - 8.25/10
Alex Riley - 6.5/10
Alicia Fox - 6/10
Big E - 7.5/10
Big Show - 8/10
Bo Dallas - 7/10
Bray Wyatt - 9.5/10
Brie Bella - 6.75/10
Brock Lesnar - 9.5/10
Brodus Clay - 6.25/10
Cameron - 4.5/10
Cesaro - 9/10
Chris Jericho - 9.5/10
Christian - 8.5/10
Cody Rhodes - 7/10
Curt Hawkins - 5/10
Curtis Axel - 6.75/10

EDIT: Fixed some shit.

Adam Rose - 5/10
AJ Lee - 7.5/10
Aksana - 3/10
Alberto Del Rio - 8.5/10
Alex Riley - 6/10
Alicia Fox - 5/10
Big E - 7.5/10
Big Show - 8/10
Bo Dallas - 7/10
Bray Wyatt - 9.5/10
Brie Bella - 6/10
Brock Lesnar - 9/10
Brodus Clay - 5.5/10
Cameron - 5.5/10
Cesaro - 9.5/10
Chris Jericho - 9.5/10
Christian - 8/10
Cody Rhodes - 8.5/10
Curt Hawkins - 5.5/10
Curtis Axel - 7/10

I guess I can give it a shot.

Adam Rose 4/10
AJ Lee 7/10
Aksana 1.5/10
Alberto Del Rio 7/10
Alex Riley 6/10
Alicia Fox 3/10
Big E 5.5/10
Big Show 7/10
Bo Dallas 4.5/10
Bray Wyatt 8/10
Brie Bella 3/10
Brock Lesnar 7/10
Brodus Clay 1/10
Cameron 1.5/10
Cesaro 7.5/10
Chris Jericho 9/10
Christian 8.5/10
Cody Rhodes 9/10
Curt Hawkins 5/10
Curtis Axel 5.5/10

Adam Rose - 3/10
AJ Lee - 8.5/10
Aksana - 3/10
Alberto Del Rio - 7/10
Alex Riley - 5.5/10
Alicia Fox - 3/10
Big E - 8.5/10
Big Show - 7/10
Bo Dallas - 9/10
Bray Wyatt - 9.5/10
Brie Bella - 5/10
Brock Lesnar - 9/10
Brodus Clay - 2.5/10
Cameron - 2.5/10
Cesaro - 8/10
Chris Jericho - 7.5/10
Christian - 6.5/10
Cody Rhodes - I THINK YOU MEANT STARDUST YOU UNCULTURED SWINE 9/10
Curt Hawkins - 3/10
Curtis Axel - 6.5/10

Adam Rose 6.5/10
AJ Lee 7/10
Aksana 2/10
Alberto Del Rio 7.5/10
Alex Riley 7/10
Alicia Fox 5/10
Big E 7.5/10
Big Show 7/10
Bo Dallas 7.5/10
Bray Wyatt 8/10
Brie Bella 2/10
Brock Lesnar 8/10 (and can go fuck off)
Brodus Clay 4.5/10
Cameron 2/10
Cesaro 8/10
Chris Jericho 8/10
Christian 7.8/10
Cody Rhodes 7.5/10
Curt Hawkins 5/10
Curtis Axel 6.5/10

Myke wrote:

Cody Rhodes - I THINK YOU MEANT STARDUST YOU UNCULTURED SWINE 9/10

made me lol

But nah, in cases where the guy has done much more with a different name, I'm using the names we've seen the wrestlers use more (like Wade Barrett).

Adam Rose - 3/10
AJ Lee - 6/10
Aksana - 4/10
Alberto Del Rio - 6.5/10
Alex Riley - 2.5/10
Alicia Fox - 2/10
Big E - 4.5/10
Big Show - 3/10
Bo Dallas - 3/10
Bray Wyatt - 8/10
Brie Bella - 5/10
Brock Lesnar - 7/10
Brodus Clay - 4/10
Cameron - 2/10
Cesaro - 8.5/10
Chris Jericho - 8/10
Christian - 4.5/10
Cody Rhodes - 7.5/10
Curt Hawkins - 1/10
Curtis Axel - 5.5/10

Adam Rose 5.00
AJ Lee 7.75
Aksana 4.00
Alberto Del Rio 8.75
Alex Riley 6.25
Alicia Fox 6.25
Big E 6.50
Big Show 8.25
Bo Dallas 7.25
Bray Wyatt 8.75
Brie Bella 6.00
Brock Lesnar 9.50
Brodus Clay 4.25
Cameron 4.25
Cesaro 8.25
Chris Jericho 9.25
Christian 8.50
Cody Rhodes 8.25
Curt Hawkins 6.50
Curtis Axel 6.50

Adam Rose - 1 (I would go lower if I could)
AJ Lee - 8
Aksana - 2
Alberto Del Rio - 6.5
Alex Riley - 3
Alicia Fox - 5
Big E - 6.5
Big Show - 7
Bo Dallas - 7.5
Bray Wyatt - 9
Brie Bella - 2.5
Brock Lesnar - 10
Brodus Clay - 4.5
Cameron - 4
Cesaro - 8.5
Chris Jericho - 8
Christian - 8
Cody Rhodes - 8.5
Curt Hawkins - 3
Curtis Axel - 5

Adam Rose - 4
AJ Lee - 7
Aksana - 3
Alberto Del Rio - 3
Alex Riley - 4
Alicia Fox - 5
Big E - 6
Big Show - 7
Bo Dallas - 1
Bray Wyatt - 8
Brie Bella - 2
Brock Lesnar - 9
Brodus Clay - 4
Cameron - 1
Cesaro - 8
Chris Jericho - 8.5
Christian - 7
Cody Rhodes - 7.5
Curt Hawkins - 4
Curtis Axel - 4

Adam Rose - 3
AJ Lee - 8
Aksana - 2.5
Alberto Del Rio - 7.5
Alex Riley - 4
Alicia Fox - 4.5
Big E - 7
Big Show - 7.5
Bo Dallas - 7.5
Bray Wyatt - 8.5
Brie Bella - 2.5
Brock Lesnar - 8.5
Brodus Clay - 5
Cameron - 2
Cesaro - 8
Chris Jericho - 8.5
Christian - 8
Cody Rhodes - 8.5
Curt Hawkins - 2
Curtis Axel - 5

Bump before I get the 2nd part posted. (for the record, you can still post and/or edit your ratings here at any time until all 4 parts of this are complete and closed)

Adam Rose 4/10
AJ Lee 8/10
Aksana 1/10
Alberto Del Rio 7/10
Alex Riley 1/10
Alicia Fox 6/10
Big E 5/10
Big Show 3/10
Bo Dallas 8/10
Bray Wyatt 10/10
Brie Bella 7/10
Brock Lesnar 9/10
Brodus Clay 6/10
Cameron 6/10
Cesaro 9/10
Chris Jericho 9/10
Christian 6/10
Cody Rhodes 8/10
Curt Hawkins 5/10
Curtis Axel 9/10

Adam Rose - 3.75
AJ Lee - 4
Aksana -1
Alberto Del Rio - 6
Alex Riley - .25
Alicia Fox - 2
Big E - 3
Big Show - 5
Bo Dallas - 4.5
Bray Wyatt - 6.5
Brie Bella - 4
Brock Lesnar - 7
Brodus Clay - 2.5
Cameron - 2
Cesaro - 5
Chris Jericho - 6.5
Christian - 4
Cody Rhodes - 5
Curt Hawkins - 2
Curtis Axel - 4

BUMP FOR RATINGS

Adam Rose 7/10
AJ Lee 10/10
Aksana 5/10
Alberto Del Rio 7/10
Alex Riley 8/10
Alicia Fox 4/10
Big E 8/10
Big Show 9/10
Bo Dallas 9/10
Bray Wyatt 10/10
Brie Bella 3/10
Brock Lesnar 9/10 (not a powerhouse on the mic, but doesn't need to be with Heyman)
Brodus Clay 5/10 (Main Event Playa huh?)
Cameron 2/10
Cesaro 9.5/10
Chris Jericho 10/10
Christian 9/10
Cody Rhodes 8.5/10
Curt Hawkins 5/10
Curtis Axel 9/10