Bored right now so I'm going to look through the XWAFF draft from back in August and try to highlight some of the best and worst picks. This is also not even to trash talk, just for discussion (which prob means trash talk tbh), and I will point out my mistakes too.
Of course this is just based on what we've seen from Weeks 1-5. I'm going to pretend that injuries didn't occur because there's nothing you can really do to prevent that. So just based off their production while healthy.
The ReachesI don't blame some of these picks that were made but some looked like a huge mistake from a mile away. The "other top options" are basically guys that were taken after them, either in that round or the very next round. I'm leaving out people who have at least had flashes of being as good as where they were drafted (examples from earlier rounds: Murray & Hill, although at least Murray should probably be on here). I'm a little more lenient after the 1st round; they have to be clear-cut over-drafted picks.
Eddie Lacy | Saintpat | Round 1 Pick 1 - Other top options: Charles, Peterson, Bell
Marshawn Lynch | Mack | Round 1 Pick 3 - Other top options: Peterson, Bell, Brown
CJ Anderson | Mexi | Round 1 Pick 14 - Other top options: Thomas, Jones, Rodgers (Bruh)
Calvin Johnson | Dead | Round 1 Pick 15 - Other top options: Thomas, Jones, Rodgers
LeSean McCoy | Dead | Round 2 Pick 2 - Other top options: Jeffery, Rodgers, Green
Lamar Miller | CB | Round 2 Pick 15 - Other top options: Murray, Hopkins, Sanders
Andre Johnson | Saintpat | Round 2 Pick 16 - Other top options: Murray, Hopkins, Sanders (Bruh)
Peyton Manning | Ruro | Round 3 Pick 4 - Other top options: Hopkins, Sanders, Randle/Ivory
Alfred Morris | Burdur | Round 3 Pick 9 - Other top options: Hopkins, Sanders, Ivory (Bruh)
Ahmad Bradshaw | Pops | Round 3 Pick 12 - Other top options: Bruh
Ameer Abdullah | Ian | Round 4 Pick 6 - Other top options: Newton, Yeldon/Martin, Marshall
CJ Spiller | Huh | Round 4 Pick 7 - Other top options: Newton, Yeldon/Martin, Marshall
Rashad Jennings | CB | Round 4 Pick 15 - Other top options: Marshall, Cooper, Allen
Mike Wallace | Burdur | Round 5 Pick 9 - Other top options: Edelman, Robinson, Decker
Roddy White | Burdur | Round 6 Pick 8 - Other top options: Bruh
Nelson Agholor | Drachen | Round 6 Pick 9 - Other top options: Bruh
Second-Half Draft Duds(Rounds 8-12 because after that it's almost entirely really bad picks
)
Charles Johnson | Mexi | Round 8 Pick 3
Tre Mason | Burdur | Round 8 Pick 8
Brian Quick | Mack | Round 8 Pick 14
Owen Daniels | Saintpat | Round 9 Pick 1
Reggie Bush | TJ | Round 9 Pick 7
Jonas Gray | Drachen | Round 9 Pick 8
Marques Colston | Moose | Round 10 Pick 1
Vernon Davis | Burdur | Round 10 Pick 8
Cody Latimer | Mack | Round 10 Pick 14
Phillip Dorsett | Pops | Round 11 Pick 12
Stedman Bailey | Mexi | Round 11 Pick 14
Trent Richardson | Dead | Round 11 Pick 15
DeVante Parker | Moose | Round 12 Pick 1
Dwayne Bowe | Dead | Round 12 Pick 2
Mohamed Sanu | Pops | Round 12 Pick 5
Denard Robinson | Drachen | Round 12 Pick 9
Harry Douglas | Mack | Round 12 Pick 14
The StealsJulio Jones (R2:1) - Moose
Aaron Rodgers (R2:5) - Pops
DeAndre Hopkins (R3:10) - Huh
Emmanuel Sanders (R3:14) - Mexi
Chris Ivory (R4:3) - Mexi
Cam Newton (R4:8) - Burdur
Brandon Marshall (R4:16) - Saintpat
Keenan Allen (R5:4) - Ruro
Tom Brady (R5:5) - Red Sox
Eli Manning (R5:8) - Drachen
Julian Edelman (R5:10) - Huh
Allen Robinson (R5:11) - Ian
Devonta Freeman (R6:6) - Ian
Jarvis Landry (R7:9) - Burdur
Allen Hurns (R9:12) - Pops
Carson Palmer (R10:7) - Huh
Charles Sims (R11:6) - Broski
Andy Dalton (R11:16) - Moose
David Johnson (R12:12) - Red Sox
Donte Moncrief (R12:15) - CB
Blake Bortles (R13:7) - TJ
Charles Clay (R13:15) - Dead
Ronnie Hillman (R15:7) - TJ
(Compared to the picks in rounds 13-15 he look like a Pro Bowl worthy pick)
Subject: An XWAFF Draft Overview 
