Cody Rhodes. Never fully understood his following, personally.

The most obvious is Randy Orton.

Randy Orton is underrated and overrated, in my opinion. Overrated by the casual wrestling fan, underrated by the IWC.

As far as the question goes, Christian is one for me. I like him, but I don't get the "OMFG Y HE NO WORLD CHAMPION?!" love for him. Never been a big Evan Bourne fan. Drew McIntyre.

^
In the WWE, Christian is presented really shitly. His true potential was shown in TNA.

Also, Del Rio maybe? Lots seem to liked him, but I've always thought he's sucked...

Rob Van Dam
The Rock (after 2004)

Any casual fan I watch wrestling with loves Jeff Hardy  

In response to some names I have seen thrown around in here...

Randy Orton - Agree that he is overrated and underrated.
Christian - Agree that he was much better in TNA.
RVD - Amazing performer, puts on awesome matches... But his mic work is dreadful.
Jeff Hardy - Puts on a show all the time. Obviously not the best wrestler, but goes out of his way to try and entertain his fans. And do drugs.
Alberto Del Rio - Nobody likes him anymore.

And in my personal opinion, I can't seem to like any of the Shield, including Dean Ambrose who I guess many people are a fan of. And Mark Henry has never entertained me, he's boring even for a big guy I think.

Randy Orton. Hate him a lot.

I've also never cared for Kofi Kingston. Don't hate him, but I think he has a good following even though I don't see anything special about him.

Yeah, never understood why anyone would like Jamaican Biscuits.

Not now, but at the time Zack Ryder. All he did was make some comical You Tube videos and most of the internet thought he should be WWE Champion

STATIC wrote:

The most obvious is Randy Orton.

 

John Cena
Randy Orton
Sheamus

CM Punk. Even though I love him too.

Zack Ryder. I hated him from the beginning. Actually, I won a meet and greet at a RAW House Show a years back and met Ryder. During the personal meet and greet, I missed the Curt Hawkins/Tyler Reks match. That kinda pissed me off.

I think Ryder is underrated. I don't see where some are getting the idea fans thought he should have been world champion. Everyone has their favorite wrestler and just because as select few want a guy as world champion doesn't mean that's what a majority of us think.

Ryder was able to get himself really over and WWE dropped the ball with him.

I know he isn't the best in the ring but neither is Ryback and they pushed him to the moon. I don't say that Ryback is overrated because people don't seem to mistake him for a great ring general or show stopper. But he played his character great like Ryder did with his. One just got a better push then the other.