Eddie Guerrero or Chris Benoit

Eddie.

This is actually a really tough one, both had fantastic matches, both had that one big title reign, both had some really great tag team runs. I think I'd edge it to Benoit, because of the Royal Rumble win, coming in first and all. Benoit vs. Angle and the triple threat at WMXX are two of my favourite matches too.

It's stupidly close though, like if I was giving one 9.5/10, the other would be getting 9.4/10.

I agree with Mink. I just feel Chris' big title win in WWE was a bigger moment than Eddie's.

but we will never hear from it again because Benoit is a murdering piece of shit.

I think Eddie's win vs Brock was one of the best moments in wrestling.

In terms of accomplishments, the edge goes to Benoit. Eddie had some amazing feuds with Malenko, Mysterio, the LWO should of taken off but sadly it didnt, that was an amazing stable. Benoit had Kevin Sullivan, the Horsemen, his broken neck in 2002 and the feel good comeback story afterwards. Both men woulda won a title again before their deaths as well, Eddie wasgoing after the WHC and even though people dont consider the ECW Title in 2007 to mean anything, Benoit was going to be the face of that brand before Punk.

benoit

Eddie. Though I like Benoit more, I think Guerrero was more loved by the fans.

Benoit, I'm a family man but he was fantastic.