Big Show or Kane?

Its pretty equal

I'd say Show, cause he's the only one to have held all 3 of the Big Three world titles.

Kane held all 3 as well. WWE in 1998, ECW in 2008 (if you really want to count that), and the World Heavyweight Championship in 2010 as well.

Close but I'll go with Kane ... he's been a "bigger" threat at times in major feuds, particularly with Undertaker

Ehh, the WHC isn't really the same as the WCW title, honestly.

Big Show has held more titles than most people. Kane has held a lot, but not the same. I prefer Kane, but Big Show has had a better career.

Kane's had more Tag Team title reigns than Show (12 vs 11), although Big Show is a 7 time world-champion, whilst Kane is a 3-time.

Kane's had "Worst Feud of the Year" almost every year lol (2002 to 2004, 2007, 2008, 2010 and 2012!), compared to Show only having two in his entire career

So, yeah I'd say Show, though Kane has the record for most career wins in WWE history

TJ wrote:

Ehh, the WHC isn't really the same as the WCW title, honestly.

Its the same title....lol

Big Show has held the major belt of the three biggest companies ever. WWE, WCW, ECW (tho It was a brand, but WWE lives in a little world)

I'd say Big Show. He was made to do less goofy stuff than Kane.

In what world is ECW one of the three biggest companies ever? Just off the top of my head CMLL, AAA, AJPW, NJPW, AJW, FMW, TNA and ROH have all been or are bigger than ECW was.

#OriolesMagic wrote:

TJ wrote:

Ehh, the WHC isn't really the same as the WCW title, honestly.

Its the same title....lol

No, it's the same prop. WWE officially recognise Triple H as the first World Heavyweight Champion, which I think is pretty clear evidence that they consider it a separate thing from the WCW title.

^^  I believe ECW was well known, but not one of the biggest companies.

Well ECW was on national TV network. ROH is widely syndicated but it doesn't cover the entire US yet.

Also ECW was able to run a lot more shows and dates. Though this is probably because ECW screwed a lot of their talent on their pay.

Mink wrote:

#OriolesMagic wrote:

TJ wrote:

Ehh, the WHC isn't really the same as the WCW title, honestly.

Its the same title....lol

No, it's the same prop.  WWE officially recognise Triple H as the first World Heavyweight Champion, which I think is pretty clear evidence that they consider it a separate thing from the WCW title.

I'm pretty sure they made a new belt for the WHC too. It always looked more sturdy than the original, the WCW title always looked really thin and flimsy. The WWE version was a lot thicker.

Even if they were bigger than ROH, there's no way in hell they were the third biggest company in the world at any point.

We've had this argument before. They were the third biggest company in America, and that matters more than internationally.

During the 90's it was WWF, WCW, ECW has the big 3. Even tho ECW was way smaller then WWF and WCW it was still a largely known company

FinestJellyBeansRaw wrote:

Even if they were bigger than ROH, there's no way in hell they were the third biggest company in the world at any point.

Oh I know

And TJ not wanting to recognize pro wrestling out of The States

TJ wrote:

They were the third biggest company in America, and that matters more than internationally.

This makes less than no sense. It makes negative sense.

CMLL sell out a 16K seater multiple times a weeks for decades, but it means nothing because they're not in America? NJPW has multiple 60K+ attendance events in the same year but that doesn't matter? Come on son.

^NJPW only became a thing when Vader's eye popped out of the eye socket in a live match. Until then, America was the only country in the world my friend. #sarcasm

Statistically Big Show had the better career.
But personally I preferred more of Kane's higher impact story-lines.

Lets be honest, both of these guys have just temporary filled main event slots for various reasons their entire WWE careers.

I'd argue that Big Show is right behind Kane as far as big men go. Kane is right behind the Undertaker. Kane's just been so good for such a long time.