This will be just like XWA's current top 200 NFL players. Will include all divas as well but no NXT superstars unless they've had a recent stint in WWE (as of right now not sure if any).

All superstars will be rated from 1-10 (quarter ratings allowed) & based on only recent years (no later than 2010). This has nothing to do with how they've been booked (main event, midcard, etc.) or any title reigns. Base your ratings on their entire skillset; the total package: in the ring, on mic, their ability to draw a crowd, their charisma, their overall entertainment factor, etc.

Any ratings of 3 over/under the INITIAL average will be considered outliers and not counted towards their total average.

This will be done in 4 parts. (4 different threads of 20 superstars to give ratings on)

Part 1 - https://xwauniverse.forumotion.com/t15727-xwa-s-current-top-50-wwe-superstars-part-1-of-4
Part 2 - https://xwauniverse.forumotion.com/t15846-xwa-s-current-top-50-wwe-superstars-part-2-of-4
Part 3 - https://xwauniverse.forumotion.com/t16044-xwa-s-current-top-50-wwe-superstars-part-3-of-4
Part 4 - https://xwauniverse.forumotion.com/t16264-xwa-s-current-top-50-wwe-superstars-part-4-of-4


Full list of superstars:

Adam Rose
AJ Lee
Aksana
Alberto Del Rio
Alex Riley
Alicia Fox
Big E
Big Show
Bo Dallas
Bray Wyatt
Brie Bella
Brock Lesnar
Brodus Clay
Cameron
Cesaro
Chris Jericho
Christian
Cody Rhodes
Curt Hawkins
Curtis Axel
Damien Sandow
Daniel Bryan
Darren Young
David Otunga
Dean Ambrose
Diego
Dolph Ziggler
Drew McIntyre
Emma
Erick Rowan
Eva Marie
Evan Bourne
Fandango
Fernando
Goldust
The Great Khali
Heath Slater
Hunico
Jack Swagger
Jey Uso
Jimmy Uso
Jinder Mahal
John Cena
JTG
Justin Gabriel
Kane
Kofi Kingston
Layla
Luke Harper
Mark Henry
The Miz
Naomi
Natalya
Nikki Bella
Paige
R-Truth
Randy Orton
Rey Mysterio
Rob Van Dam
The Rock
Roman Reigns
Rosa Mendes
Rusev
Ryback
Santino Marella
Seth Rollins
Sheamus
Sin Cara
Summer Rae
Tamina Snuka
Tensai
Titus O'Neil
Triple H
Tyson Kidd
Undertaker
Wade Barrett
William Regal
Xavier Woods
Yoshi Tatsu
Zack Ryder

You should keep the 1-10 scale and go with quarter points.

Burdurman wrote:

This will be just like XWA's current top 200 NFL players. Will include all divas as well but no NXT superstars unless they've had a recent stint in WWE (as of right now not sure if any).

They will be rated from 1-5 stars & based on only recent years (no later than 2010). Nothing to do with how they've been booked & any title reigns. Base your ratings strictly on their entire skillset in the ring, on mic, their ability to draw a crowd, their charisma, their overall entertainment factor, etc.

I'm making this post from my phone so I'll add any other details later, just been forgetting to post this for the past 2-3 days.

Post here if interested to give ratings.

NXT is in WWE though.

Is it just guys that are in WWE right now, or will you be including guys that have left recently? Like with Alberto, or Brodus, or whoever, there's still quite a lot to judge them on since 2010.

Ian wrote:

You should keep the 1-10 scale and go with quarter points.

Eh, I'll keep the 1-10 scale I guess. Quarter points doesn't sound like a bad idea either but idk, might be TOO many possible ratings.

@ Mink, right now I'm thinking about adding anyone who has left in 2014 as well but not sure.

Another thing I'll edit into the first post is that there will be an outlier system for this list as well. Right now I'm thinking it will be any ratings 2.5 above or below the average, if I go with a 1-10 scale & quarter point ratings. If it's just half points I might bump that up to 3 or if it's a 1-5 scale then that number will obviously be lowered a good amount.

I'll have to think about what would work best.


All of this is fine to be up for discussion (encouraged actually) within the next few days. I won't be starting this right away.

Another thing... after everything gets decided and I'm ready to start setting this up I'll send a mass PM for this list to hopefully get more people involved than the other one. More wrestling fans on here so should be more regardless.

Cool. Much better than the NFL thing, we have a much nicer and welcoming environment here.

I pick Shawn Michaels

You should be clear about what we're ranking. Is it just in-ring work or is it "the total package"

I was clear. Nobody ever reads my stuff.

Burdurman wrote:

Base your ratings strictly on their entire skillset in the ring, on mic, their ability to draw a crowd, their charisma, their overall entertainment factor, etc.

Total package

If it's the total package, then Lex Lugar.

Bret Hart = 4/10

^ Current


Anyone have a list of every WWE superstar that has left the company in 2014? If not I'll be searching it up, but could be missing some if I don't find a complete, updated list for that anywhere.

& thoughts on including superstars that have left this year? Maybe counting former superstars only starting from when WWE they had that big release day of jobbers?

Bump for feedback on any of the above. Also, anyone else that's 100% gonna be taking part in this? Right now the interest is looking weak.  

Batman wrote:

Cool. Much better than the NFL thing, we have a much nicer and welcoming environment here.

Just don't rate Cena too high or Daniel Bryan too low or Dead might start yelling at you.

Dead doesnt count as people.

Adam Rose
AJ Lee
Aksana
Alberto Del Rio
Alex Riley
Alicia Fox
Big E
Big Show
Bo Dallas
Bray Wyatt
Brie Bella
Brock Lesnar
Brodus Clay
Cameron
Cesaro
Chris Jericho
Christian
Cody Rhodes
Curt Hawkins
Curtis Axel
Damien Sandow
Daniel Bryan
Darren Young
David Otunga
Dean Ambrose
Diego
Dolph Ziggler
Drew McIntyre
Emma
Erick Rowan
Eva Marie
Evan Bourne
Fandango
Fernando
Goldust
The Great Khali
Heath Slater
Hunico
Jack Swagger
Jey Uso
Jimmy Uso
Jinder Mahal
John Cena
JTG
Justin Gabriel
Kane
Kofi Kingston
Layla
Luke Harper
Mark Henry
The Miz
Naomi
Natalya
Nikki Bella
Paige
R-Truth
Randy Orton
Rey Mysterio
Rob Van Dam
The Rock
Roman Reigns
Rosa Mendes
Rusev
Ryback
Santino Marella
Seth Rollins
Sheamus
Sin Cara
Summer Rae
Tamina Snuka
Tensai
Titus O'Neil
Triple H
Tyson Kidd
Undertaker
Wade Barrett
William Regal
Xavier Woods
Yoshi Tatsu
Zack Ryder


80 superstars on the list. Includes current WWE superstars (that have been on the main roster wrestling on Raw/SD) and mostly all superstars released during or after WWE's June releases this year. Post here if you think there should be any changes / additions. I'll be starting this within the next few days.

Looks good to me.

Updated the first post to include the first two parts of the rating process of this list in case anyone missed any and can't find them. (although you could also check your PMs)

Final part posted. Links to all 4 parts can be found in the first post of this thread.


In about a week I'll start to actually form the list. Will announce either 5 or 10 superstars at a time (probably once each day) starting from #50.

GET YOUR RATINGS POSTED, INCLUDING ANY PARTS YOU MAY HAVE MISSED.

Will send a final PM tomorrow as a reminder for any final ratings over the next 24-48 hours. For now I'll be bumping these old ones and make sure to add your ratings if you missed any.

Excel saved me a ridiculous amount of time with this. Was able to do this so much more quickly than I was expecting, even after realizing I could do it really quickly on Excel.

THE LIST IS COMPLETE. Will be announcing many parts of this list, starting probably pretty soon. Stay tuned!