HomeHomeSearchRegisterLog in
Share
 

 XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30

View previous topic View next topic Go down 
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyTue Jun 21, 2016 6:12 pm

I'm bringing this back with a new twist. Ratings will be decided based on 4 categories. The scale will still be 1-10 in each category (with .5 ratings allowed) and they will be averaged into one core number rating. Then there will be an average between each person's ratings. Probably won't eliminate outlier ratings this time but people shouldn't be giving ridiculous ratings just because.. Funny

It'll only include superstars from the main roster. Also, you should only judge each superstar based on what they've done & how they've performed since WrestleMania 30 until now. It doesn't matter how much they've done or how long they've been on WWE's main roster in that time span... it's about how well they've done. Although it's fair to give someone more credit over another due to a larger sample size of matches/promos/feuds they've had with the company.

Before we start, I want to see how many people would actually get involved with this. Also in the mean time, we should discuss what those 4 categories should be exactly.

The criteria:

Ring Work - How well they perform in matches would obviously be needed.

Mic Skills - Seems obvious to add as well BUT the question is, would this category be unfair to certain superstars who are great in many areas but simply can't work the mic (or are barely even given the opportunity to)?... I would say yes it should be included since you need it to be the total package.

Drawing Ability - Ability to draw/entertain a crowd, sell tickets/merchandise, and get fans behind/against them.

&

Maybe...

Consistency? - I think this could be a category. Certain superstars shine at times and flop at other times while some of the top superstars are consistently great. You can count on them to deliver on almost any given night.

Or maybe...

Storytelling? - This could include both storytelling in matches & in storylines/feuds.

We could go with either consistency, storytelling or some other criteria that's brought up in this thread. Maybe even make it 5 categories to add more factors to consider.

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyTue Jun 21, 2016 6:33 pm

Also I think this will be a good time to do this with the roster split draft coming up. We can kinda compare how the site views WWE's superstars with how they view their own superstars in a kayfabe sense of when they are drafted.

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyTue Jun 21, 2016 11:48 pm

#FeelTheBern

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
MooseNugget
TeamMoose
TeamMoose
MooseNugget

Posts : 22312
Join date : 2013-07-23
Age : 28
Location : Kotzebue, AK

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyTue Jun 21, 2016 11:54 pm

Drawing ability? Everyone should be low in that department except for John Cena AYY

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Sig
Back to top Go down
http://www.joshuajhadley.com
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyWed Jun 22, 2016 12:00 am

Man, if Cena is supposed to be the apex of drawing ability then Reigns should be pretty high up there too on resemblance. Cena Troll

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
MooseNugget
TeamMoose
TeamMoose
MooseNugget

Posts : 22312
Join date : 2013-07-23
Age : 28
Location : Kotzebue, AK

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyWed Jun 22, 2016 12:08 am

I guess you don't pay attention to ratings or house show attendance.

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Sig
Back to top Go down
http://www.joshuajhadley.com
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyWed Jun 22, 2016 12:26 am

I don't cause those things aren't determined by one guy. clown

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
Dragon Fx
KingofSwing
KingofSwing
Dragon Fx

Posts : 9016
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyWed Jun 22, 2016 1:25 am

Burdur, this is why no one responds to your threads clown
Back to top Go down
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyWed Jun 22, 2016 4:52 pm

I try to bring good discussion. Thirsty Mofos

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
Dragon Fx
KingofSwing
KingofSwing
Dragon Fx

Posts : 9016
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyWed Jun 22, 2016 6:42 pm

And ruin all of them by being a clown clown
Back to top Go down
Guest
Guest



XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyWed Jun 22, 2016 7:47 pm

Since wrestlemania 30? So since 2014?

Obviously the Shaq in the Rumble.
Back to top Go down
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyThu Jun 23, 2016 2:52 am

Yeah, at first I was gonna make it since WM 31 but then I figured why not add an extra year and go for an even number with WM 30.

Also, that makes it only me doing this? I aint bothered

Not sure if everyone who has posted would want to do these ratings or not? I don\'t know

Anyone who would like to take part in this, post in this thread and say so. You wouldn't be obligated to do it, I just wanna know the interest level, just a general number of people I could expect to give ratings for each superstar if I do this.

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
MooseNugget
TeamMoose
TeamMoose
MooseNugget

Posts : 22312
Join date : 2013-07-23
Age : 28
Location : Kotzebue, AK

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyThu Jun 23, 2016 8:22 am

I'd take part I aint bothered

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Sig
Back to top Go down
http://www.joshuajhadley.com
Eeyen
Icon
Eeyen

Posts : 13976
Join date : 2013-07-19
Age : 26

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyThu Jun 23, 2016 9:22 am

I would take part, but if you think Reigns' tour dying and Ambrose's tour flourishing at the same time isn't indicative of Reigns' failure as a draw then I'm out. The only segment of the crowd that seems to like him is the women.

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 8ac976ca6f8befeaa023cc0b0a1abb84
WHERE AM I
Back to top Go down
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyThu Jun 23, 2016 11:30 pm

Wait, so if I think that then you're out & not taking part? clown

That's 3 people now tho. Thirsty Mofos

Drachen? Zanon? Anyone else?

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
Eeyen
Icon
Eeyen

Posts : 13976
Join date : 2013-07-19
Age : 26

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyFri Jun 24, 2016 12:20 am

If you think that you're CB in disguise clown

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 8ac976ca6f8befeaa023cc0b0a1abb84
WHERE AM I
Back to top Go down
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyThu Jun 30, 2016 2:55 pm

#FeelTheBern There's gotta be some kind of interest for this?

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
MooseNugget
TeamMoose
TeamMoose
MooseNugget

Posts : 22312
Join date : 2013-07-23
Age : 28
Location : Kotzebue, AK

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyThu Jun 30, 2016 11:53 pm

peace

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Sig
Back to top Go down
http://www.joshuajhadley.com
Batman
I am Batman
I am Batman
Batman

Posts : 19193
Join date : 2013-07-23
Age : 24
Location : Learning maturity

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyFri Jul 01, 2016 9:31 pm

Burdur, I know you jack off Roman Reigns, but he's not a good draw. Getting shit on everywhere he goes when he's trying to get cheered isn't a good thing. I aint bothered

____________________
.

Favorite Current Wrestlers:
1. Seth Rollins
2. AJ Styles
3. Kevin Owens
4. Shinsuke Nakamura
5. John Cena

Favorite All-Time Wrestlers:
1. The Undertaker
2. CM Punk
3. Daniel Bryan
4. Triple H
5. Stone Cold Steve Austin
Back to top Go down
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyFri Jul 01, 2016 11:59 pm

I don't even LOVE Roman Reigns I just think he gets way too much hate that he doesn't deserve. For example, I like Rollins & Ambrose waaaaaaaaaay more but that doesn't mean Reigns shouldn't have been WWE champion when he was.

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
Guest
Guest



XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptySat Jul 02, 2016 5:29 am

I'm in
Back to top Go down
Eeyen
Icon
Eeyen

Posts : 13976
Join date : 2013-07-19
Age : 26

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptySat Jul 02, 2016 9:35 am

I'll do it even if Burdumb is dumb.

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 8ac976ca6f8befeaa023cc0b0a1abb84
WHERE AM I
Back to top Go down
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptySat Jul 02, 2016 2:33 pm

Alright I'll probably start this soon and hope that some of the others commenting in this thread will join in and maybe some others that haven't posted yet.

What do people think about the categories? We can go with 3 or up to 5 of them.

Ring Work / Mic Skills / Drawing Ability / Consistency? / Storytelling? / Something else?

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
Damn Sam
Icon
Damn Sam

Posts : 16486
Join date : 2013-07-23

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyMon Jul 04, 2016 4:51 pm

Coach Smurf wrote:
What do people think about the categories? We can go with 3 or up to 5 of them.

Ring Work / Mic Skills / Drawing Ability / Consistency? / Storytelling? / Something else?

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Ffa0e0c138a7e33418097902c8194563
Back to top Go down
http://www.wrestling-united.com
Eeyen
Icon
Eeyen

Posts : 13976
Join date : 2013-07-19
Age : 26

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 Empty
PostSubject: Re: XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30   XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 EmptyMon Jul 04, 2016 6:40 pm

I don't know man. NAH

____________________
XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30 8ac976ca6f8befeaa023cc0b0a1abb84
WHERE AM I
Back to top Go down
 

XWA's Current Top 50 WWE Superstars Since WrestleMania 30

View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Wrestle Fanatics :: The Squared Circle :: World Wrestling Entertainment-