Everyone make your ratings based on their recent production/accomplishments/skillset. That doesn't mean base it off of only last season, but what they have done recently should be a huge factor into the rating that you give them. If you want to look back at their careers to try to justify (to yourself) that they are still as good as they used to be or anything like that when making your rating, that is fine and up to your personal preference. But we will be rating them mainly on the present and very recent past.

Rate each player from 1-10 (1/2 ratings allowed). You can judge what each rating between the 1-10 scale means to you (ex: 1 = out of the league in a few years, 10 = future HOF, etc. is really up to you) but try to stay consistent with those ratings for each player/position.

Any ratings that are 2.5+ points under or over the average rating will be considered outliers and won't be counted.


Anthony Fasano
Antonio Gates
Brandon Myers
Brandon Pettigrew
Brent Celek
Charles Clay
Coby Fleener
Delanie Walker
Dennis Pitta
Garrett Graham
Greg Olsen
Heath Miller
Jared Cook
Jason Witten
Jermaine Gresham
Jermichael Finley
Jimmy Graham
Jordan Cameron
Jordan Reed
Joseph Fauria
Julius Thomas
Kyle Rudolph
Ladarius Green
Marcedes Lewis
Martellus Bennett
Mychal Rivera
Owen Daniels
Rob Gronkowski
Rob Housler
Scott Chandler
Tim Wright
Tyler Eifert
Vernon Davis
Zach Ertz
Zach Miller

Darrel Young
Greg Jones
Jed Collins
Jerome Felton
John Conner
John Kuhn
Marcel Reece
Michael Robinson
Mike Tolbert
Vonta Leach

Dallas Clark and Tony Gonzalez retired

Shit, I had that in mind too then forgot anyway. Good catch

Anthony Fasano - 5.5
Antonio Gates - 8
Brandon Myers - 6
Brandon Pettigrew - 6
Brent Celek - 6
Charles Clay - 7
Coby Fleener - 7.5
Delanie Walker - 6
Dennis Pitta - 7.5
Garrett Graham - 6
Greg Olsen - 8
Heath Miller - 7
Jared Cook - 6.5
Jason Witten - 9
Jermaine Gresham - 6
Jermichael Finley - 6
Jimmy Graham - 10
Jordan Cameron - 8.5
Jordan Reed - 7
Joseph Fauria - 5
Julius Thomas - 9
Kyle Rudolph - 8
Ladarius Green - 6
Marcedes Lewis - 6.5
Martellus Bennett - 6.5
Mychal Rivera - 5
Owen Daniels - 8
Rob Gronkowski - 9.5
Rob Housler - 5
Scott Chandler - 7
Tim Wright - 6
Tyler Eifert - 7
Vernon Davis - 9
Zach Ertz - 7
Zach Miller - 6.5

Darrel Young - 6
Greg Jones - 6.5
Jed Collins - 6.5
Jerome Felton - 8
John Conner - 7.5
John Kuhn - 8.5
Marcel Reece - 8.5
Michael Robinson - 7
Mike Tolbert - 9
Vonta Leach - 8

Dont nobody wanna rate FBs

Don't be a pussy

Anthony Fasano - 4
Antonio Gates - 8
Brandon Myers - 5
Brandon Pettigrew - 6
Brent Celek - 6.5
Charles Clay - 7
Coby Fleener - 7.5
Delanie Walker - 7.5
Dennis Pitta - 8
Garrett Graham - 5.5
Greg Olsen - 8
Heath Miller - 7.5
Jared Cook - 6.5
Jason Witten - 9
Jermaine Gresham - 6.5
Jermichael Finley - 6.5
Jimmy Graham - 10
Jordan Cameron - 8.5
Jordan Reed - 7.5
Joseph Fauria - 5
Julius Thomas - 8.5
Kyle Rudolph - 8.5
Ladarius Green - 6.5
Marcedes Lewis - 7
Martellus Bennett - 7
Mychal Rivera - 5.5
Owen Daniels - 6.5
Rob Gronkowski - 9
Rob Housler - 5
Scott Chandler - 6
Tim Wright - 6
Tyler Eifert - 7
Vernon Davis - 8.5
Zach Ertz - 7.5
Zach Miller - 7

Darrel Young - 4
Greg Jones - 6.5
Jed Collins - 5.5
Jerome Felton - 7
John Conner - 6.5
John Kuhn - 7
Marcel Reece - 7.5
Michael Robinson - 7.5
Mike Tolbert - 8.5
Vonta Leach - 8

Anthony Fasano 6.0
Antonio Gates 7.0
Brandon Myers 5.5
Brandon Pettigrew 6.5
Brent Celek 7.0
Charles Clay 8.0
Coby Fleener 7.5
Delanie Walker 8.0
Dennis Pitta 8.0
Garrett Graham 7.0
Greg Olsen 7.5
Heath Miller 7.5
Jared Cook 8.0
Jason Witten 8.5
Jermaine Gresham 7.5
Jermichael Finley 7.5
Jimmy Graham 9.5
Jordan Cameron 8.5
Jordan Reed 8.0
Joseph Fauria 7.0
Julius Thomas 8.5
Kyle Rudolph 8.5
Ladarius Green 8.5
Marcedes Lewis 7.5
Martellus Bennett 7.5
Mychal Rivera 7.0
Owen Daniels 6.5
Rob Gronkowski 8.5
Rob Housler 6.5
Scott Chandler 6.5
Tim Wright 6.5
Tyler Eifert 8.0
Vernon Davis 8.0
Zach Ertz 7.5
Zach Miller 7.0

Darrel Young 7.0
Greg Jones 6.5
Jed Collins 6.5
Jerome Felton 8.0
John Conner 8.0
John Kuhn 7.5
Marcel Reece 8.0
Michael Robinson 7.0
Mike Tolbert 7.5
Vonta Leach 7.0

I'll probably put up the next list within the next 24-48 hours regardless but come on guys we need more than 3 peoples' ratings...

Anthony Fasano 6.5
Antonio Gates 7.5
Brandon Myers 5.5
Brandon Pettigrew 6.5
Brent Celek 7
Charles Clay 7.5
Coby Fleener 7
Delanie Walker 8
Dennis Pitta 8
Garrett Graham 6.5
Greg Olsen 7.5
Heath Miller 7.5
Jared Cook 7.5
Jason Witten 8.5
Jermaine Gresham 7
Jermichael Finley 7
Jimmy Graham 9.5
Jordan Cameron 9
Jordan Reed 8
Joseph Fauria 6
Julius Thomas 9
Kyle Rudolph 8.5
Ladarius Green 7.5
Marcedes Lewis 7.5
Martellus Bennett 7
Mychal Rivera 6.5
Owen Daniels 6.5
Rob Gronkowski 9.5
Rob Housler 6.5
Scott Chandler 6.5
Tim Wright 6.5
Tyler Eifert 8
Vernon Davis 9
Zach Ertz 7.5
Zach Miller 7

Darrel Young 7
Greg Jones 6.5
Jed Collins 7.5
Jerome Felton 8
John Conner 8
John Kuhn 7.5
Marcel Reece 8.5
Michael Robinson 8
Mike Tolbert 7.5
Vonta Leach 7